Virgil’s Aeneid told Romans how the flight of a Trojan survivor could lead, generations later, to their own city’s greatness. When Virgil died in 19 BCE, that story had become a major model for Latin poetry. The tradition offered other Roman poets plenty of material. They wrote about Romans killing Romans, brothers fighting over a throne, a perilous voyage for the Golden Fleece and the struggle with Hannibal. In their hands, epic could explore the Roman experience beyond the origins recounted by Virgil.

The five poets wrote at different points in Roman history. Lucan belonged to Nero’s reign, while Statius, Valerius Flaccus and Silius Italicus composed their major works in the later first century CE. Cornelius Severus was an Augustan poet, closer in time to Virgil, whose work survives only in fragments. The first four left lengthy narratives that readers can still follow. Ancient Romans could still read and admire Severus’ works, although later centuries failed to preserve them.

Epic was usually a long narrative in dactylic hexameter, the formal metre of Homer’s Greek poems. Roman writers had their own predecessors, including Ennius, who treated Rome’s history as material for heroic poetry. Virgil drew these traditions together in the Aeneid. Later poets inherited Virgil’s metre and familiar scenes while finding new ways to examine family loyalty, political authority, the worth of victory and the conduct expected of a hero.

1. Lucan: Rome’s Civil War Without a Hero

Bust of Lucan in Córdoba, Roman Epic Poets
Lucan (Marcus Annaeus Lucanus) honored in a modern bust in Córdoba, Spain. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Marcus Annaeus Lucanus, known as Lucan, was born in 39 CE at Corduba, today’s Córdoba in Spain. He had influential connections: his uncle Seneca was a philosopher and an adviser to the emperor Nero. Lucan initially prospered in Nero’s literary circle, before the two men fell out. Implicated in a plot against the emperor in 65 CE, he died at about twenty-five. By then he had written a deeply disturbing epic about Rome’s civil wars.

Lucan’s Bellum Civile, also known as the Pharsalia, survives in ten books. Its subject is the civil war between Caesar and Pompey that began with Julius Caesar’s crossing of the Rubicon in 49 BCE. The defeat of Pompey’s army at Pharsalus in 48 BCE is the central military disaster. Writing almost a century after those events, Lucan could look back on the destruction of the old republican order from a world ruled by Caesar’s imperial successors.

Romans fighting other Romans are the horror announced at the beginning of the poem. In Book 1, Caesar presses forward with the force of something destructive and unstoppable, while Pompey is likened to an old oak whose reputation outlasts its strength. The images distinguish the commanders: Caesar drives events, while Pompey has enormous prestige but struggles to exercise it. Neither fits the customary image of a Roman hero.

The difference from the Aeneid goes beyond subject matter. Virgil’s Aeneas must act within a future arranged by the gods, even when his personal wishes conflict with it. Lucan has no divine council directing a chosen hero’s progress. Gods and fate are mentioned, and supernatural horrors belong to the story, but Olympian figures do not descend to protect their favourites in battle. Human decisions bring about the republic’s destruction, and the poem offers little confidence that the universe will set matters right. The supernatural episodes deepen that sense of dread.

Book 6 contains the most disturbing of them. Sextus Pompey consults Erichtho, a Thessalian witch, to discover what lies ahead. She forces a dead soldier back into speech and extracts a prophecy of Rome’s coming misery. The revived body offers neither genuine restoration nor comforting knowledge. Where a traditional epic hero might descend among the dead to learn his destiny, Lucan has a corpse dragged into the living world to describe the horrors ahead. The familiar epic encounter with the dead becomes another expression of civil war’s horrors.

At Pharsalus in Book 7, Lucan dwells on the slaughter without allowing Caesar’s success to become proof of virtue. Pompey escapes the battle only to be murdered in Egypt. Caesar continues the campaign, but victory does not establish him as the poem’s hero. Lucan sympathizes strongly with the republican cause while remaining severe toward its leading men. Pompey’s vanity and indecision are visible, and those who defend liberty have themselves helped fill the battlefield with Roman dead.

Cato the Younger provides the clearest moral opposition to Caesar. In Book 9, after Pompey’s death, he guides the surviving republicans through the deserts of North Africa. His endurance and refusal to measure virtue by success set him apart from commanders consumed by the struggle for power. Yet he cannot rescue the political cause he serves. Lucan has already captured that tension in his famous early contrast between the victorious cause favoured by the gods and the defeated one supported by Cato. The distinction precedes the great battle, so the reader has been asked to consider it long before the final outcome.

The extant epic stops in Book 10 while Caesar is in Alexandria. Readers never reach the end of the civil war or Caesar’s assassination. Some have wondered whether Lucan meant to write twelve books in response to Virgil’s twelve, but the surviving poem cannot settle the question of his intended length. As it stands, the narrative leaves Roman political violence without the kind of completed historical destiny provided by the Aeneid.

Ancient accounts of Lucan’s death also shaped his later reputation. In Tacitus, Annals 15.49 and 15.70, Nero’s resentment of the young poet’s literary standing forms part of their quarrel. Tacitus also relates that Lucan recited verses about a dying soldier while bleeding to death himself. This is an ancient report; the scene cannot be independently verified. It encouraged readers to see a connection between the poet’s fate and his depiction of violence. The rhetorician Quintilian praised Lucan’s energy and forceful observations, although he thought the work better suited as a model for public speakers than for poets. Lucan’s Roman contemporaries did not agree on his merits.

2. Statius: The War at Thebes and the Price of Hatred

Scanned pages of Statius’s Thebaid with Latin text and headings
Latin edition of Statius’s Thebaid. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Publius Papinius Statius lived and wrote in the world of Naples and Rome during the Flavian dynasty, especially under Domitian. Alongside the occasional poems collected in the Silvae, he composed the twelve-book Thebaid, finished in the early 90s CE. He chose a story well known from Greek mythology and tragedy: the rivalry of Oedipus’ sons, Eteocles and Polynices, for the kingship of Thebes.

The brothers are meant to take turns ruling Thebes, but Eteocles holds on to the throne when his allotted year ends. Polynices seeks help from Adrastus, king of Argos, and the expedition of the Seven Against Thebes sets out to enforce his claim. The succession dispute grows into a family vendetta. In Book 1, their blind, isolated father Oedipus calls upon the Fury Tisiphone to punish the sons he believes have forsaken him. His curse carries the family’s quarrel into the lives of the people who must fight it.

Divine intervention runs throughout Statius’ story. The Furies inflame revenge, while Jupiter and other gods argue, observe and act. Their involvement gives no protection to the people caught in the war. The Thebaid follows the consequences of a dynastic conflict as warriors leave their own homes to fight for one brother against the other. Parents, wives and whole cities suffer for a claim to the throne that began within a single household.

Much of Statius’ narrative concerns events before the assault on Thebes. Tydeus’ embassy ends in an ambush, and the prophet Amphiaraus joins an expedition whose ruin he foresees. When drought interrupts the Argive march near Nemea, Hypsipyle, once queen of Lemnos, shows the soldiers where to find water. In Book 5, she tells how the women of Lemnos killed the island’s men. Meanwhile, the infant Opheltes, whom she has left in her care, dies from a serpent’s attack. The funeral games held for him in Book 6 delay the advance still further. The march has already brought death to a household before the Argives reach Thebes.

Hypsipyle’s memories of violence in her own home prepare readers for the losses ahead at Thebes. The death of Opheltes gives the soldiers a child to mourn, and the games in his honour provide another arena for men to seek distinction. Heroic competition takes place amid grief. The Thebaid makes the costs of this war apparent well before its principal battles begin.

The fighting brings a series of deaths, each with a different character. Mortally wounded, Tydeus turns his rage on the severed head of his enemy. Capaneus insults the gods and Jupiter strikes him down. Parthenopaeus, still young, dies far from his mother. Statius makes room for their bravery, cruelty and recklessness, but he never lets the reader forget that all have been drawn into a feud over the kingship of Thebes.

Eteocles and Polynices finally meet in Book 11 and kill one another, fulfilling the hatred that has governed the story. Nor does their enmity disappear after death. In Book 12, the new ruler Creon prohibits the burial of Polynices. His sister Antigone and his wife Argia try to honour the body anyway. When it is placed on the pyre burning for Eteocles, the flames divide, as though the brothers remain enemies even in death. The mythical division of the flames gives visible form to the brothers’ undiminished hostility.

The closing movement takes the story beyond the brothers. Women from Argos, mourning the men denied proper burial, seek help from Theseus, ruler of Athens. He defeats Creon and restores the funeral rites in Book 12. Their relatives can finally mourn the dead, although nothing can restore their lives. Where the brothers used kingship to pursue their quarrel, Theseus exercises authority to stop the cruelty that survives the fighting. The poem ends with a test of political power in the treatment of the dead.

Statius also worked on the Achilleid, an epic intended to cover Achilles’ life. Only Book 1 and part of Book 2 remain, concentrating on the hero’s youth. His mother, the sea-goddess Thetis, hopes to keep him out of the Trojan War and disguises him as a girl among King Lycomedes’ daughters on Scyros. There he becomes involved with Deidamia, who later bears his child. The surviving story often sounds lighter than the Thebaid, yet Deidamia experiences sexual coercion, which prevents the episode from being read as harmless romantic play. The surviving narrative also makes clear how Achilles’ approaching military career determines the fates of those close to him.

Dante portrays Statius in the Divine Comedy as a Christian convert who travels with Dante and Virgil through Purgatory. Nothing reliable in the ancient evidence establishes a conversion by the historical poet. Dante’s Statius is a literary invention, and his presence shows the very different meanings later readers found in the Thebaid. The historical Statius’ surviving epic confronts the damage rulers inflict, the rights owed to the dead and the consequences of a murderous family dispute.

Advertisements

3. Valerius Flaccus: Jason, Medea and the Voyage of the Argo

The eight surviving books of Gaius Valerius Flaccus’ Argonautica retell Jason’s voyage to Colchis, on the Black Sea, to recover the Golden Fleece. Valerius probably composed the poem under Vespasian and his successors in the later first century CE. The heroes sail aboard the Argo, following a tradition already given a major Greek epic by Apollonius of Rhodes. His Argonautica provided an important model, while Virgil’s influence shaped the way Valerius presented the voyage for Roman readers.

Valerius addresses Vespasian near the beginning, placing the expedition within the literary world of an emperor. The address alone cannot establish that every discovery and victory celebrates Roman conquest. Jason speaks and acts as a heroic captain, but his fortunes depend on gods, strangers and circumstances beyond his control. His celebrated companions must survive dangerous coasts and shifting alliances as well as fight. In the opening book, their departure already brings consequences for Jason’s family and for those he leaves behind.

The voyage repeatedly exposes the limits of individual prowess. On Lemnos, the crew encounters a community shattered by violence; at Cyzicus, the sailors become involved in fatal fighting with former hosts. Hercules is separated from the expedition after the disappearance of Hylas, his young companion. In Book 4, the vessel faces rocks that close together and threaten to destroy it. Athena and Juno intervene to help it pass. Valerius makes the crossing an ordeal of seamanship, terror and divine assistance, unlike Lucan’s battles where Olympian protectors never arrive to rescue their favourites.

In Colchis, Jason enters the conflicts surrounding King Aeetes, the ruler who possesses the Golden Fleece. Foreign adventurers find themselves involved in a kingdom’s military and political affairs. The story then turns to Aeetes’ daughter Medea. Her knowledge of magic can secure the prize for Jason, but helping him means betraying her father’s household. She is attracted to the newcomer, while Juno and Venus influence that attraction. Valerius therefore leaves the reader to consider how much freedom Medea possesses in a choice that will estrange her from her family.

Medea’s help is indispensable when Jason must harness fire-breathing bulls and face the serpent guarding the fleece. He remains courageous, but courage alone cannot complete his assigned tasks. Valerius gives the woman whose magic makes his achievement possible a story of her own. Her knowledge grants her influence over the outcome while her decision costs her the security of her household. Jason’s celebrated success comes at a heavy cost to Medea.

In Book 8, Medea flees Colchis with Jason, the two participate in a wedding ceremony, and her brother Absyrtus pursues the Argo. When the crew urges Jason to surrender Medea to avoid another war, she demands an answer about the promises he made to her. Jason is still trying to reassure her when the poem breaks off. The flight and pursuit have already begun when the text ends. The surviving work contains neither the completed homeward voyage nor the later tragedies found in other versions of Medea’s life.

Whether Valerius left the work unfinished or later manuscript transmission removed its ending is unknown. Quintilian refers to his recent death in the survey of Latin poets, evidence that the poet was known to a near-contemporary, but no guide to the intended conclusion. Scholars have therefore examined the marriage that the surviving narrative does describe. In a study of marriage in Valerius’ epic, Emma Buckley argues that Medea’s precarious standing as Jason’s wife gives the closing dispute particular importance for the poem’s treatment of Roman power and obligation.

Valerius’ account gives the voyage a different emphasis from those of Apollonius and Virgil. The Argo ventures into new seas and brings armed men into other people’s conflicts. Jason’s command succeeds through help that carries a high price for Medea. Her part in the story goes beyond helping Jason, while the catastrophes of later versions of Medea’s life still lie ahead. The unfinished narrative stops precisely when her expectations of Jason have become a problem that the hero cannot easily evade.

Advertisements

4. Silius Italicus: Hannibal’s War as a Roman Epic

Manuscript page from Silius Italicus’s Punica (Vatican Ottob. lat. 1258)
Manuscript page from Silius Italicus’s Punica (Vatican, Ottob. lat. 1258). Source: Wikimedia Commons

Silius Italicus turned to Roman history in the Punica, a seventeen-book work and the longest complete Latin epic surviving from antiquity. He recounts the Second Punic War of 218 to 201 BCE, beginning with Hannibal’s attack on Saguntum and proceeding through Rome’s disasters in Italy to Scipio Africanus’ victory at Zama. Writing long after the war, Silius drew upon accounts of its events and earlier epic poetry to explore how Romans explained their survival and what qualities they claimed for themselves.

Silius knew the dangerous workings of imperial government. He held the consulship in 68 CE, toward the end of Nero’s reign, and subsequently governed Asia. Pliny the Younger portrays him as a cultivated landowner who retired to his estates to write poetry. Pliny also records criticism of his earlier conduct: he was thought to have served as an informer under Nero. His career thus belonged to the uneasy years in which Roman officeholders survived the fall of the Julio-Claudian dynasty and adjusted to Flavian rule.

His reverence for Virgil became a matter of comment among contemporaries. According to Pliny, Letters 3.7, Silius celebrated Virgil’s birthday with greater care than his own and visited the poet’s monument near Naples almost as a sacred place. The letter does not claim that he bought Virgil’s tomb. It does show the regard in which he held his predecessor. The Aeneid had described Juno’s anger and the legacy of Dido. Silius recalled both when he opened his own epic with divine hostility toward Rome, drawing the war against Carthage into an established poetic tradition.

Hannibal’s campaign gave Silius a succession of devastating battles to recount. The Carthaginian general crosses the Alps, defeats Roman forces at the Trebia and Lake Trasimene, and destroys another army at Cannae in 216 BCE. Silius narrates these battles through moments of command, fear, skill and mass killing. Hannibal appears as a brilliant and dangerous opponent whose victories expose Rome’s vulnerability. Hannibal’s skill and repeated victories make Rome’s eventual resistance a demanding epic subject.

Military events are only one part of the Punica. Gods enter the fighting, moral qualities appear as characters, and commanders illustrate different ways of responding to danger. Fabius Maximus avoids the great decisive encounter Hannibal seeks, earning the name Cunctator, the Delayer. His patience contrasts with the impatience of commanders seeking immediate glory. Silius sets battlefield daring against the self-restraint on which the survival of a threatened state can depend.

In Book 15, the young Scipio must choose between Pleasure and Virtue, appearing as figures who promise different futures. Pleasure offers comfort and security; Virtue asks him to accept hardship, danger and public duty. He follows Virtue. Readers familiar with the traditional Choice of Hercules would recognise the pattern, now applied to Rome’s struggle with Carthage. Silius presents Scipio’s later triumph as an expression of the disciplined character he has elected to pursue, alongside the achievements of command and battle.

Hannibal, meanwhile, has the resolve and daring usually associated with epic protagonists. His hostility to Rome, expressed in an oath, gives direction to extraordinary military efforts and risks. Yet Silius’ divine framework and his knowledge of Rome’s eventual survival rule out a final Carthaginian victory. Silius allows readers to admire Hannibal’s abilities while opposing his aims. At times his story commands as much attention as that of the Roman who finally defeats him.

The poem repeatedly returns to people who bear the consequences of those campaigns. Besieged cities, mourning families and ruined armies occupy the narrative long after the immediate result of a battle is clear. Scholars have examined the relationship between such suffering and Rome’s eventual triumph, including the treatment of bodies and funeral rites. A study of funerals in the Punica considers how Hannibal handles Roman corpses and how the epic later depicts Scipio’s triumph. The dead remain present even in an epic celebrating Roman survival.

After Zama, Scipio returns home at the end of the narrative. Readers interested in Scipio’s victory over Hannibal can learn from Silius how a much later Roman author interpreted that victory, while remembering that he did not witness the war. The Punica is an epic response to history rather than a substitute for the historical record. Its divine interventions, invented speeches and crafted character portraits remain literary elements even where the conflict itself was real.

Advertisements

5. Cornelius Severus: An Epic Poet Known Through Fragments

Cornelius Severus is known much less fully than the other four poets. He lived in the Augustan literary world and was therefore a contemporary of Virgil rather than a member of the later Flavian generation. Ancient writers regarded him as a poet of historical epic, but none of his complete works has survived. Quotations and critical judgments offer the principal evidence for what he wrote. Romans knew many more epics than the few that have survived intact.

Quintilian mentions an epic on a Sicilian conflict, generally called the Bellum Siculum. In the Institutio Oratoria 10.1.89 he praises Severus’ verse-making and reports particular admiration for its first book. Scholars often identify the subject as Octavian’s struggle with Sextus Pompey, who held Sicily during the conflicts after Julius Caesar’s assassination. Although plausible, this identification rests on a brief notice that cannot establish the full narrative or the poet’s attitude toward the war.

Seneca the Elder supplies a longer passage of Severus’ poetry in Suasoriae 6.25-26. It describes the death of Cicero in 43 BCE and the display of the orator’s head and hands on the rostra, the platform from which Roman politicians addressed the people. Severus treats the silencing of this republican voice with the emotional power of epic. We cannot securely identify the larger poem from which Seneca quoted, however. The lines should not be assigned to the Bellum Siculum simply because that is another title associated with Severus.

Severus and Lucan both used Roman bloodshed as material for epic. Both treated Rome’s internal bloodshed as a subject for elevated poetry, although Severus was already doing so in the Augustan age. Lucan did not originate the idea of writing epic about civil war. Lucan’s surviving narrative treats the subject at much greater length. Since Severus’ poetry has largely vanished, the precise connections between their approaches cannot now be traced.

Severus was not the only poet whose work survived mainly through other writers. Quintilian also speaks favourably of Albinovanus Pedo. Seneca the Elder quotes a passage associated with Germanicus’ northern voyage in which sailors fear the hostile, unfamiliar waters beyond the world they know. The Latin fragment conveys the terror of an ocean that seems to exceed human experience. It suggests how Roman poets could make imperial exploration resemble a mythic venture, while leaving the complete poem and many details of its original context uncertain.

Two manuscript fragments reused around a binding spine, showing narrow columns of Latin text
Two manuscript fragments making up a single strip used around the spine of a binding. Text is part of the Corpus Iuris Civilis, issued from AD 529-534 by order of Emperor Justinian I. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Which poems survive now depended on centuries of copying, quotation and chance. A poem could attract admiration in the first century and still disappear if its manuscripts wore out or ceased to be copied. Old manuscript leaves were sometimes cut up and reused in medieval bookbindings, occasionally leaving fragments that scholars can identify. The fragments illustrated here belong to Roman law, not to a missing epic. For Severus, it is Seneca’s quotations and Quintilian’s comments that permit even a partial understanding of the poet’s work.

Each of the five poets found different uses for Roman epic. Lucan made civil war a test of republican virtue and the meaning of victory; Statius examined a royal family’s destructive hatred and the duty to bury its dead. Valerius followed the Argonauts while tracing the obligations Jason incurred toward Medea. Silius used Hannibal’s war to consider the strengths Rome believed had preserved it. Cornelius Severus survives chiefly in quotation, leaving us to glimpse the historical epics that Romans once read beside the familiar works of Virgil and his successors.