On 14 January 1506, workers digging in a Roman vineyard uncovered a group of marble figures: a bearded man, two boys and enormous serpents twisting around all three. Scholars soon recognized the subject as Laocoön and His Sons, a sculpture praised by a Roman writer more than fourteen centuries earlier. Artists could now study an ancient marble group that made human struggle its subject. The discovery soon became a famous event in the recovery of classical art.

The man is Laocoön, a Trojan priest remembered for warning his city against a wooden horse left behind by the Greeks. According to the story, the horse concealed armed enemies, but before Laocoön’s warning could save Troy, sea serpents attacked him and his children. The marble shows the attack in progress. The father twists against the coils, with his sons caught on either side of him, and the viewer sees how little strength can do to save them.

The marble group is now in the Vatican Museums. Pliny the Elder names its sculptors in an ancient description, yet historians still dispute when the statue was made, who first owned it and whether it followed an older Greek model. The central figure’s right arm was also reconstructed in a position that proved wrong when an ancient fragment was recovered centuries later. Its history reaches from Trojan legend and Roman collecting to Renaissance sculpture, later debates about artistic expression and modern conservation.

A Roman vineyard reveals the Laocoön in 1506

Laocoon group Vatican Museums. Aka the Laocoon sculpture
The Laocoon group as displayed in the Vatican Cortile del Belvedere Source: Wikimedia Commons

The vineyard belonged to Felice de Fredis, and the find was made on 14 January 1506 on the Esquiline Hill, near the church of Santa Maria Maggiore. Rome had been rebuilt repeatedly over its ancient neighbourhoods, so buried antiquities were regularly found in excavations. Its size and state of preservation attracted attention immediately. The Uffizi’s account of the discovery confirms the vineyard owner’s identity and the discovery date, both of which appear in accounts tracing the sculpture’s later history.

Pope Julius II was collecting prominent works of ancient sculpture and sent Giuliano da Sangallo, an architect, to see what had been unearthed. Michelangelo joined him, along with Sangallo’s young son Francesco. In a letter of 28 February 1567, Francesco recalled descending into the excavation with his father and hearing him identify the sculpture as Pliny’s Laocoön. The Digital Sculpture Project’s documentary chronology reproduces his words in Italian. Francesco was a child when he witnessed the find, and his recollection is valuable. Written roughly sixty-one years later, it cannot be taken as an exact transcript of the conversation.

Pliny had described the subject in enough detail for Sangallo to recognise it. Pliny described a sculpture showing Laocoön, his children and the attacking snakes. He also named three sculptors from Rhodes and said the work had stood in the residence of the emperor Titus. The excavated marble closely matched the subject. Even so, it has not been possible to identify the exact room in which Pliny saw it or to prove that the statue discovered in 1506 had remained in its original Roman setting throughout antiquity.

Julius II acquired the group for the Vatican, where he installed it in the Cortile delle Statue. That sculpture courtyard later became the Octagonal Court. The Vatican Museums describe this courtyard as the beginning of the papal collections of classical statuary. The Laocoön was displayed alongside the Apollo Belvedere, another celebrated antique. By placing both statues in the papal collection, Julius presented his Rome as the heir to the artistic prestige of the emperors.

News of the discovery travelled through visitors’ reports, sketches, prints and descriptions. For artists studying ancient sculpture, the Laocoön offered something difficult to find among surviving works: a group of figures whose bodies were bound together by a single violent action. Pliny’s praise had made the work famous in writing. Its recovery let artists inspect how the sculptors arranged straining limbs and intertwined bodies in marble.

The Trojan priest who warned against the wooden horse

First century AD Pompeii fresco showing Laocoon story from Greek literary tradition predating Virgil
Pompeii wall painting depicting the death of Laocoon and his sons Source: Pompeii in Pictures

Laocoön’s story belongs to the legends about Troy, the city on the northwestern Anatolian coast besieged by the Greeks. When the Greeks seemed to withdraw, they left a huge wooden horse outside its walls. Soldiers were hidden inside and would attack after the Trojans dragged the structure into the city. The story had circulated long before Virgil wrote the Aeneid in the late first century BCE. Ancient writers disagreed about the priest’s actions and why the gods punished him.

In Book 2 of Virgil’s Aeneid, lines 40 to 56, the priest comes down from Troy’s citadel to urge his fellow Trojans to distrust the abandoned horse. A gift offered by their enemies, he argues, may conceal another attack. He throws a spear into its side, and the hollow structure rings with the impact. Readers know the warning is justified because Virgil has already made the danger clear. The Trojans, trying to interpret the Greek withdrawal and the signs before them, still do not see what is hidden inside.

The attack follows later in Virgil’s second book, lines 199 to 233. Laocoön is sacrificing a bull when two immense snakes swim across the sea from Tenedos. They seize his sons first. He struggles to reach the children, but the coils wrap around his own body and neck. After the three are killed, the snakes retreat to the shrine of Minerva, whom the Greeks called Athena. The Trojans decide that Laocoön has been punished for striking a sacred gift. That conclusion helps persuade them to bring the horse through their walls, exactly as the Greeks intended.

Virgil lets his readers recognise the trap while the Trojans mistake the deaths for a warning from the gods. They interpret the killing as a divine warning against rejecting the horse, although the victim had recognized the danger correctly. The episode forms part of Aeneas’s account of Troy’s fall. In Roman legend Aeneas escaped and became an ancestor of the people who would eventually found Rome. The Vatican’s collection entry emphasizes that connection: the Trojans’ destruction is also the beginning of a Roman story about origins and ancestry.

Other writers assign different reasons for the snakes’ attack. In Hyginus, Fabulae 135, Laocoön serves Apollo and has disobeyed the god by marrying and having children. Apollo sends the snakes as the priest sacrifices to Neptune. The Trojans still believe the deaths are punishment for striking the horse, but the narrator supplies a separate motive. Hyginus also names the sons Antiphas and Thymbraeus, names that are absent from the passage in Virgil.

Laocoön fares differently again in the Greek epic Quintus Smyrnaeus, Posthomerica 12. Athena blinds him, the serpents kill his sons, and the priest survives to grieve. No inscription identifies which version of the legend the sculptors followed. It depicts Laocoön caught in the serpents’ attack. The familiar account in Virgil cannot safely be made the sole key to interpreting the group, especially while the date of the marble remains contested.

Romans encountered this story in domestic decoration as well as poetry. A painting in Pompeii’s House of Menander depicts an episode involving Laocoön and belongs to a wider series drawn from Trojan myth. The house was excavated largely between 1926 and 1932, and the photographic archaeological record of House I.10.4 records the scene in a room near the atrium. The episode appeared in poetry, monumental sculpture and the decoration of private houses. There is no basis for claiming from the painting alone that its artist copied the Vatican marble or that it was painted before Virgil composed his poem.

Advertisements

How the marble sculpture makes the struggle visible

The sculptors brought three bodies of different ages into one tightly interlocked composition. Laocoön braces himself on a support resembling an altar and twists violently as one serpent bites near his hip. His left arm rises against a coil; his right, restored with the recovered ancient fragment, bends back close to his head. His two sons struggle on either side. Their smaller frames make the father’s heavily developed muscles more conspicuous, while the snakes connect the figures without making their movements identical.

Each son responds differently to the attack. One collapses into a contorted position and looks close to being overwhelmed. The other holds himself more upright, although he too has been caught by a serpent. As viewers move around the work, they can see the coils crossing torsos and limbs, open spaces cut deep into the group and contrasting textures of hair, skin and scales. The figures belong to one action, but the sculptors gave each a separate response to his danger.

The priest’s face raises a different question. His brow tightens and his head tilts as he opens his mouth, yet the opening is far smaller than the cry described by Virgil. The difference later became central to arguments about suffering in poetry and sculpture. The face itself admits several readings. Pain, physical effort, terror for his sons and the knowledge that he cannot escape may all be visible to a viewer, but no inscription tells us which emotion the artists intended to dominate.

The powerful anatomy and exaggerated bodily movement are commonly associated with Hellenistic art. The term refers to Greek artistic traditions that developed after Alexander the Great’s conquests and continued into the Roman period. Sculptors working in these traditions often explored violent action, complex poses and intense feeling, unlike the more composed standing figures associated with classical sculpture of the fifth century BCE. Laocoön’s pronounced abdominal muscles and deeply worked hair fit that broader approach, though comparison of style cannot determine the statue’s year of production.

The sculptors assembled the group from several blocks of stone. The art-historical analysis by Amanda Herring for Smarthistory identifies six blocks of Greek Parian marble in its construction. Joints could be hidden by anatomical features or serpent coils, and working with separate pieces helped sculptors manage projecting limbs. The joins show something of how the sculptors managed the difficult projections, although the full carving process cannot be reconstructed. Modern restoration has also changed some visible surfaces, so not every detail now on display can be assumed to be untouched antique workmanship.

The marble may also have looked different in its original setting. Ancient sculpture could be painted. Studies of ancient polychromy, or painted sculpture, have shown that classical statuary was not always left white. But the Laocoön’s own colouring has not been reconstructed with confidence. Illustrations showing brightly painted serpents or flesh tones are possibilities proposed by modern interpreters, not direct records of its ancient appearance.

Pliny named the artists but left the date unresolved

Our main ancient text is Pliny the Elder’s Natural History 36.37, written in the first century CE. Pliny praises a statue of Laocoön, his children and the serpents that stood in the emperor Titus’s house, naming Hagesander, Polydorus and Athenodorus as the three artists from Rhodes. He thought it superior to works in both painting and bronze. He gives no date for its carving, says nothing about its patron and does not tell us whether the group was derived from an older design or where the sculptors made it.

Pliny also says that the group was carved from one block of stone, a description contradicted by the several pieces of marble in the surviving sculpture. The joins may have been hard to see, or Pliny may have repeated a claim about the work without examining its construction. The discrepancy does not erase his testimony about the subject and the artists. It does mean that his words need the same critical scrutiny as any other ancient account, even when the writer may have had access to the object.

The artists’ names point to Rhodes, an island with an important sculptural tradition and links to other centres of the late Hellenistic world. Archaeological finds at Sperlonga, south of Rome, have added another complication. In 1957, large marble groups depicting myths were discovered in a grotto connected with the emperor Tiberius. One sculptors’ inscription includes names related to those preserved by Pliny. The inscription invites comparison with the Laocoön. Similar names alone cannot establish that the same men carved both groups.

Researchers have also compared the marbles. In an American Journal of Archaeology study published in 2015, Matthias Bruno, Donato Attanasio and Walter Prochaska examined seventeen samples taken from the Sperlonga sculptures. Their analysis identified stone from the Docimium quarries in present-day Turkey and supported a date under Tiberius for the Sperlonga ensemble. The Vatican Laocoön has instead been associated with Parian marble, making a joint origin for the groups more difficult to assume. These results tell us about the Sperlonga material; they do not provide a laboratory date for the Vatican statue itself.

Each source answers a different part of the question. Pliny’s account preserves an ancient attribution. The Sperlonga inscription supplies names recorded on another group. Scientific testing identifies marble sources, while comparisons of pose and carving reveal stylistic relationships. They help scholars assess how the works might be connected, but none gives a precise production year for the Vatican Laocoön. The surviving evidence does not yet allow a secure chronology for the Vatican group.

Advertisements

Was the Laocoön a Greek original or a Roman copy?

The Vatican Museums favour a date of approximately 40 to 30 BCE, toward the end of the Hellenistic period. Others have placed the group in the early Roman Empire or proposed that it reproduces an earlier bronze sculpture. The Ashmolean Museum’s object record for a cast considers a bronze prototype probable, whereas the Vatican describes the surviving marble as a late Hellenistic masterpiece. The disagreement concerns how to interpret the surviving work and its artistic ancestry; neither museum possesses a dated commission that settles the issue.

The distinction between a Greek original and a Roman copy is often difficult to apply. Romans who had money and status collected Greek art, and sculptural workshops made versions of admired Greek compositions for wealthy Roman buyers. A Greek artist might work for a Roman patron, translate a bronze design into marble or reshape an established composition for a different setting. A marble statue made in the Roman world with Greek methods and a Greek subject cannot always be assigned neatly to one side of an ‘original’ versus ‘copy’ distinction.

Some historians have proposed a connection with the culture of Augustus, who ruled Rome from 27 BCE to 14 CE. His household promoted the tradition that the Roman people descended from Aeneas, the survivor of Troy. An image of the Trojan disaster might have appealed to patrons living in that political and cultural environment. A 2007 University of Maryland research thesis on the group in Augustan Rome develops the case for viewing the group in Augustan Rome. That remains an interpretation of its possible context, since no surviving commission identifies an Augustan patron or explains why the subject was chosen.

The uncertain date also affects the sculpture’s relationship to Virgil. A work carved around 40 to 30 BCE would predate the finished Aeneid, on which Virgil worked until he died in 19 BCE. If the marble is later, the poem might have influenced its design. The artists and poet could equally have drawn independently on earlier Trojan stories, many of which no longer survive. Neither the sculpture’s pose nor the differences among the texts establish a certain sequence of influence.

The secure facts are more limited than many museum labels or illustrations imply. The marble was excavated in Rome in 1506 and depicts the same mythological group Pliny praised in the first century CE. Pliny attributed that work to three sculptors from Rhodes. We still cannot name the original patron, establish an exact date or decide whether the composition came from an earlier prototype. Until those questions are resolved, the statue’s place in the history of Greek and Roman workshops remains uncertain.

Renaissance artists copied it, argued over it and competed with it

Bandinelli's 1520s Laocoon copy commissioned by Pope Leo X showing baroque restoration with upraised arm
Baccio Bandinelli’s marble copy of the Laocoon group created 1520-1525. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Renaissance artists had studied anatomy and the human body long before the Laocoön was uncovered. Michelangelo, for one, was an established sculptor long before 1506, and the discovery cannot explain his knowledge of anatomy. What it provided was an exceptionally ambitious ancient example of three figures and two snakes arranged in one scene of strenuous movement. Its anatomy and interlocking movement gave sculptors a demanding ancient example against which to test their own work.

Baccio Bandinelli made that rivalry literal by carving a full-sized marble version. Commissioned in 1520, the copy was first intended for Francis I, king of France, as a diplomatic gift. It eventually went to Florence instead. The Uffizi’s detailed catalogue entry dates Bandinelli’s work to 1520 to 1525 and specifies Luni marble. Bandinelli’s Luni marble differs from the Parian stone identified in the ancient Vatican group.

Bandinelli produced his own complete interpretation of a damaged ancient sculpture. He supplied missing arms, adjusted some forms and placed his signature on the work. Giorgio Vasari later wrote that Bandinelli had made a wax model for the ancient Laocoön’s missing right arm as well. His copy demonstrates both the interest Renaissance sculptors took in the work and the freedom they had to supply missing parts. The discovery of an ancient arm fragment later challenged some of those restorations.

Drawings, casts and printed images allowed artists beyond Rome to encounter the sculpture. The Metropolitan Museum of Art preserves a sixteenth-century woodcut caricature that replaces the priest and his sons with apes is an especially curious example. The sixteenth-century woodcut is attributed to Nicolò Boldrini and may have followed a design by Titian, though both its attribution and the purpose of the joke remain debated. The joke depended on viewers recognizing the Laocoön’s arrangement of three bodies and serpents.

Its influence also reached subjects far removed from Troy. Jan Gossart, a Netherlandish painter who travelled to Rome, used similarly strained and twisting forms. Maryan Ainsworth’s analysis for the Met finds a connection with the antique sculpture in Gossart’s Christ Carrying the Cross. There, bodily contortion conveys suffering in a Christian scene. Artists could borrow ideas about gesture and anatomy from Laocoön without repeating the priest’s story or copying the entire group.

Advertisements

The missing arm changed the statue for four centuries

Bent right arm reaching backward installed 1957 replacing centuries of baroque restoration with upraised arm
Detail of the Laocoon showing the correct bent right arm discovered 1905 by Ludwig Pollak Source: Wikimedia Commons

At the time of the excavation, the priest’s right arm was missing. The missing limb left an important part of the composition open to interpretation. A raised, extended arm could make Laocoön appear to be pushing heroically against the serpent. An arm bent sharply towards his head would confine the struggle closer to his body. Different artists proposed both arrangements, and neither could be confirmed until a fragment of the ancient arm came to light.

Restorers gradually supplied missing parts. Giovanni Angelo Montorsoli, who had worked in Michelangelo’s circle, made an early intervention; Agostino Cornacchini added further work in the eighteenth century. There was no single replacement arm that remained untouched throughout the next four hundred years. Vatican News’s account of the restorations describes several successive interventions that reflected changing opinions about the likely pose, the authority of earlier artists and the appearance the sculpture should present to the public.

In 1906, the antiquarian Ludwig Pollak offered the Vatican a marble fragment he believed might be Laocoön’s missing right arm. It had been discovered in a Roman stonecutter’s workshop and was sharply bent at the elbow, unlike the extended arm then familiar to viewers. The Vatican did not immediately fit the fragment to the statue. Conservators first had to assess its measurements, worked surface and relationship to a shoulder altered by earlier restoration, as well as decide which later additions could safely be removed.

Filippo Magi eventually directed the restoration undertaken from 1957 to 1959. The Vatican describes the removal of later additions and the reattachment of Pollak’s fragment. With the right arm bent backwards near the priest’s head, the whole movement became more concentrated than in the extended-arm version. Some artists had proposed the bent arm before the fragment was identified. The popular claim that Michelangelo knew the correct position in 1506 comes from later recollection and should be handled with care, even though the recovered ancient stone confirms the bent pose.

Pollak did not survive to witness the restoration. He was a Jewish scholar living in Rome during the Nazi roundup of Roman Jews in October 1943. He was deported to Auschwitz with his family and was killed there. The Vatican Museums’ archival account of Pollak records his donation and the unsuccessful attempts to protect him. His recognition of the fragment was an essential contribution to the study of the Laocoön, and his life and death also belong to the history of the object now displayed in the Vatican.

For centuries, paintings, prints and plaster casts had reproduced a Laocoön whose arm stretched away from his head. That restored version became the image generations accepted as the ancient masterpiece. The statue in the modern Vatican has a different outline, supported by the surviving bent arm. Older images record how the restored work looked for centuries; the surviving ancient fragment establishes the bent gesture.

Why eighteenth-century writers argued about his expression

By the eighteenth century, Laocoön’s face had become central to arguments about artistic expression. Johann Joachim Winckelmann, a German scholar, discussed it in 1755 in his Thoughts on the Imitation of Greek Works. He believed Greek sculpture could convey great suffering without excessive outward display and admired what he termed noble simplicity and quiet grandeur. In the priest’s relatively restrained expression, Winckelmann saw an example of the ideal he thought made Greek art exceptional.

Gotthold Ephraim Lessing challenged Winckelmann’s explanation. In Laocoön: An Essay on the Limits of Painting and Poetry, published in 1766, he drew attention to the contrast between Virgil’s loudly crying priest and the statue’s comparatively small open mouth. He argued that a poet can lead readers through a succession of actions in time, while a sculptor must choose a single visible moment. In his view, a permanently screaming face would disrupt the visual beauty of the stone group, giving the sculptors a reason to restrain the expression that did not depend on the priest’s heroic self-control.

For Winckelmann and Lessing, Laocoön raised the question of what poetry could describe and what a sculptor could show. The question reached well beyond Laocoön’s courage. A 2020 scholarly study, Crying Laocoon: The Visual Arts of Translation examines their arguments about the limits of words and images and the ways art can be translated between them. Their disagreement also reveals how much the interpretation of an ancient object can reflect the aesthetic assumptions of much later writers.

Neither theory gives us direct access to the sculptors’ intentions. We can observe the size and shape of the priest’s mouth, but calling it a statement of Stoic endurance or a deliberate compromise made for beauty goes beyond what the marble establishes. It is equally uncertain that the artists even knew Virgil’s finished poem. A poet could narrate the attack over time; the sculptors had to convey it through a single arrangement of bodies.

From Napoleon’s Paris to the Vatican, and beyond

El Greco Laocoon shows divine punishment and Trojan priest suffering with Toledo cityscape background
El Greco oil painting interpreting the Laocoon myth with Apollo and Artemis observing, Source: Wikimedia Commons

After entering the Vatican in 1506, the Laocoön remained there for nearly three centuries before Napoleon’s campaigns brought it to Paris. France imposed the Treaty of Tolentino on the papacy in 1797, and the Laocoön was among the antiquities taken to Paris. It arrived at the Louvre in 1798 and was displayed prominently in the Musée Napoléon. An image in the Louvre’s record of an 1804 medal places it at the end of a gallery, revealing how important the sculpture had become as a symbol of political possession. After Napoleon’s defeat, it was returned to the Vatican in 1815 to 1816.

Artists continued reinterpreting the story rather than merely reproducing the Vatican marble. El Greco painted his Laocoön around 1610 to 1614; it is now held by the National Gallery of Art in Washington. He set the attack against a landscape evoking Toledo, the Spanish city where he lived. The elongated, pale bodies and the puzzling figures standing on the right create an unsettling treatment of the Trojan myth. The identity of the figures remains disputed, and the painting’s possible religious meanings extend beyond the ancient sculpture.

The identities of the figures at the right remain open to interpretation. They have sometimes been called Apollo and Artemis, while other writers suggest different mythological or allegorical witnesses. The National Gallery of Art does not regard the question as resolved. El Greco’s authorship, the approximate date, the location of the painting and its Laocoön subject can be established without presenting an uncertain interpretation as an identifying fact.

Research on the ancient group continues to address the sculptors’ workshop, the marble, the many restorations and its influence on later artists. The Vatican’s collection record still assigns it to the late first century BCE while acknowledging the disputed date. Other scholars prefer an early imperial origin or argue that an older composition lies behind it. The suggested settings range from a late Hellenistic commission to a Greek workshop serving Roman collectors or a Roman-period adaptation of an older Greek design.

The Laocoön’s story is unusually well documented in some respects and elusive in others. We know when it came out of the Roman vineyard, can follow its effect on Renaissance artists and have physical evidence for the correct position of the right arm. Pliny’s account, the Pompeian painting and the finds at Sperlonga also allow us to ask difficult questions about its ancient origins. The statue in the Vatican’s Octagonal Court now has an arm that Renaissance visitors never saw, and its artistic history has become fuller without yielding a final answer about the men who commissioned and carved it.