Some places are holy to communities that understand their history in very different ways. Jews and Muslims attach distinct religious meanings to the Temple Mount, or Haram al-Sharif, in Jerusalem. In Sri Lanka, several faiths have identified the same footprint-shaped hollow on a mountaintop with different sacred figures. Each place has a history shaped by more than one religious community.
Shared sacred ground does not always mean that different worshippers meet under a common set of rules, or that they are perpetually in conflict. Some buildings changed religious function under new governments. Others have remained sites of simultaneous devotion with sharply divided custodial rights. The Church of the Holy Sepulchre is administered mainly through agreements between Christian churches. At the Western Wall, disagreements over Jewish worship exist alongside the larger political conflict over Jerusalem.
At all eight places, religious memory affects decisions about access and authority. Belief helps explain why people come to them; institutions and political decisions help explain who can enter, worship, repair a shrine or describe its history officially. Those arrangements have changed over time, and each site has its own history of cooperation or dispute.
The Temple Mount and Haram al-Sharif in Jerusalem

In Jerusalem’s Old City, the raised sanctuary is the Temple Mount, or Har ha-Bayit, in Jewish usage, and al-Haram al-Sharif, the Noble Sanctuary, in Muslim usage. Jewish tradition places the ancient temples on this ground. For Muslims, the precinct contains the Dome of the Rock and the prayer building commonly called the al-Aqsa Mosque. Christians also recognise it as part of biblical Jerusalem and the setting of episodes connected with Jesus. The communities refer to one platform, although they approach its buildings and sacred history through different practices.
The biblical account in 2 Chronicles 3:1 places Solomon’s temple on Mount Moriah. Tradition commonly dates that First Temple to the tenth century BCE, but the exact date and plan cannot be verified through excavation of the sanctuary itself. A second temple arose following the Babylonian exile and was substantially enlarged under Herod the Great in the late first century BCE. The Romans destroyed it in 70 CE during the Jewish revolt. Herod’s works transformed the precinct into an immense platform with retaining walls, although the surviving masonry also records other periods of construction.
The precinct gained a central place in Islamic religious life during Islam’s early centuries. Qur’an 17:1 speaks of Muhammad’s night journey from the Sacred Mosque to the Farthest Mosque. The verse does not name Jerusalem; Islamic interpretation and devotion established the association with this sanctuary. The Umayyad caliph Abd al-Malik built the Dome of the Rock in the late seventh century, while the southern prayer hall took shape across several early Islamic building phases. Its golden dome consequently belongs to a later historical setting than the Jewish temples, despite their common location.
Traditions surrounding the exposed Rock beneath the dome also differ. Jewish interpretations have associated the mountain with the beginning of creation, God’s presence and the binding of Isaac, although identifying this particular rock developed in religious tradition over time. Muslims connect the sanctuary with Muhammad’s night journey and ascent. Neither the Qur’anic verse identifies the rock precisely as the departure point, nor does the biblical narrative of Abraham’s sacrifice describe the present monument. The distinctions are important to any account of the site’s past.
In modern times, access and authority over the compound have become major issues in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Following Israel’s capture of East Jerusalem in 1967, Israeli authorities controlled security and entry, while the Islamic Waqf, with Jordanian custodianship, administered Muslim religious activities. The established arrangement generally reserved worship for Muslims while permitting non-Muslim visits, but its meaning and application remain contested. In 2026, arguments over Jewish prayer and limits on Muslim entry again exposed the disagreement. UNESCO’s Old City record acknowledges the Old City’s importance to Judaism, Christianity and Islam; it does not decide sovereignty, property rights or the rules for worship.
The decisions affect practising believers today. Many Jews regard the temple’s destruction and absence as a central part of their religious memory; Jewish religious authorities disagree among themselves about the permissibility of entering the mount. For Muslims, al-Aqsa remains a functioning place of prayer. The arrangement of gates, policing, archaeology and access therefore shapes daily religious life, rather than simply determining who may visit an ancient monument.
The Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem

Elsewhere in the Old City stands the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. It encloses places Christians associate with Golgotha, where Jesus was crucified, and the tomb connected with his burial and resurrection. The church itself is centuries later than the events of the Gospels. Emperor Constantine supported a monumental Christian complex here during the fourth century after the area’s earlier Roman transformation. Destruction, repairs and expansions followed, leaving a building with Byzantine, Crusader and more recent features.
Excavations beneath the church help reconstruct the setting in which the identification developed. Francesca Romana Stasolla’s team at Sapienza University has documented old quarrying activity and subsequent alterations to the ground. The archaeological sequence is consistent with an area once lying outside Jerusalem’s earlier urban boundary where tombs could exist. It does not identify the occupant of a particular burial place or prove a Christian theological claim.
The building accommodates six Christian churches with recognised, though unequal, rights. The Greek Orthodox, Armenian Apostolic and Roman Catholic churches, represented in the Catholic case by the Franciscans, exercise the main custodial powers. The Coptic Orthodox, Syriac Orthodox and Ethiopian Orthodox communities hold more restricted spaces and liturgical privileges. Because each denomination maintains its own worship and hierarchy, the use of a chapel, the placement of a lamp, a staircase or the timing of a service may have consequences far beyond its apparent scale.
The regulations are known as the Status Quo. They formalised older practices rather than establishing equal control for every Christian group. A historical study of the regulations traces an essential Ottoman decree to 1852, a further decree to 1853 and international recognition to the Treaty of Berlin in 1878. By protecting established rights, the rules also restricted changes that any one community might make independently. A ladder on an exterior ledge is often cited as an illustration of these restrictions, although the claim that it has stood in exactly the same position since 1728 exceeds what the evidence can establish.
Even opening the main entrance involves an arrangement between communities. The Muslim Joudeh family traditionally keeps the church key, while the Muslim Nuseibeh family carries out the opening and closing. They connect these responsibilities with medieval Jerusalem, especially Saladin’s recapture of the city in 1187. The precise origins of the practice and its uninterrupted duration are less securely documented than popular accounts suggest. The families do not administer Christian rites or own the church. Their inherited responsibilities allow the Christian custodians to share an entrance without putting it wholly under one denomination’s control.
The custodians sometimes work together, including on substantial restoration and excavation undertaken while worship continues. Negotiations are still necessary because repairing even a portion of the building could affect an established claim to its use. At the Holy Sepulchre, sharing takes a specific institutional form: Christian denominations divide its custodianship, and Muslim families perform a civic duty at its door. Muslims and Christians do not hold equal religious ownership of the church.
The Cave of the Patriarchs and Ibrahimi Mosque in Hebron

At Hebron, called al-Khalil in Arabic, the Cave of Machpelah lies beneath a monumental sanctuary revered by Jews, Christians and Muslims. Religious traditions place the tombs of Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Rebecca, and Jacob and Leah here. Genesis 23 describes Abraham’s purchase of the cave and surrounding field from Ephron for Sarah’s burial, including the price and the witnesses. The passage grounds an ancestral burial tradition for Jews. Ibrahim, the Islamic name for Abraham, is an equally important figure in Muslim religion, while Christians know the ancestral account through the Bible.
The enclosure above the cave is commonly dated to the period of Herod the Great, at the transition between the first century BCE and the first century CE. Its enormous dressed limestone blocks remain visible through later renovations. UNESCO’s description of Hebron’s old town describes an early Roman-period monument that subsequently drew pilgrims of the three religions. The standing architecture establishes the age of the sanctuary, not the identity of those buried in the cave, which is inaccessible to ordinary investigation. The burial identifications belong to inherited sacred traditions.
The building passed through several religious administrations. Christians worshipped there under Byzantine rule. Following the Muslim conquest it became associated with a mosque, until the Crusaders made it a church. Saladin’s reconquest in 1187 returned it to Muslim worship. Each phase left architectural traces. The names Tomb of the Patriarchs and Ibrahimi Mosque consequently refer to different religious relationships with the same building and burial tradition.
Regulations governing entry have often reflected the rulers in power. Jewish access was limited in the later Ottoman era and at other times. Following Israel’s occupation of the West Bank in 1967, Jewish entry expanded and tensions around the sanctuary intensified. In February 1994, Baruch Goldstein, an Israeli settler, shot dead 29 Muslims praying inside the mosque. Security measures imposed afterward separated Muslim and Jewish worship in large parts of the complex. That division followed a modern massacre and cannot be explained adequately as the inevitable result of ancient doctrinal disagreement. It remains tied to occupation and the lives of Hebron’s Palestinian population.
The enclosure now contains areas for Jewish worship and others for Muslim worship, with access arrangements changing on certain religious holidays. Christians also revere the place, but their religious access is not administered on an equivalent basis. Communities share traditions about the patriarchs while their ability to worship near the cave is determined by present-day authorities. The physical division in Hebron reflects modern decisions about access to a sanctuary revered by several religions.
Hagia Sophia in Istanbul

Hagia Sophia was erected in Constantinople, capital of the Eastern Roman Empire, as its great imperial church. Justinian I completed the present building in 537 after an earlier church had been destroyed in the Nika revolt. Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus, its architects, devised an immense domed interior that later influenced both Byzantine ecclesiastical architecture and Ottoman mosque design. The dedication is to Holy Wisdom, rather than to a woman saint called Sophia.
For most of the following nine centuries, Hagia Sophia stood at the heart of imperial Orthodox ceremony. Latin Christian control after the Fourth Crusade in 1204 interrupted that role. Mosaics, marble and the vast central space connected worship with the authority of the emperor and the city. After Mehmed II captured Constantinople in 1453, the church became an Ottoman imperial mosque. Christian mosaics alongside a mihrab, minbar, minarets and Ottoman calligraphy now record successive uses. UNESCO’s account of Istanbul’s historic areas notes the building’s influence in both Byzantine and Ottoman architectural traditions.
The Ottoman conversion changed the decoration over several periods, with mosaics treated differently at different times. Individual mosaics were concealed, modified, repaired or revealed at different times. Hagia Sophia continued as a mosque until a Turkish government decision of 1934 converted it into a museum, which opened in 1935. Visitors could then examine Byzantine Christian and Islamic material in the same monumental setting. The museum also belonged to the early Republic’s programme of secularisation.
In July 2020 the Turkish government returned Hagia Sophia to use as a mosque. Many Muslims welcomed the change, regarding the earlier museum decision as an injustice. Christian communities and heritage experts raised concerns about conservation and access. ICOM and ICOMOS called for protecting the building’s successive historical layers whatever its religious status. It has continued as an active mosque while arrangements for cultural visitors and conservation have been revised over time.
Hagia Sophia remained religiously important to some Christians after its conversion to a mosque and continued to retain Islamic associations when it became a museum. It was first a church, then a mosque, then a museum and finally a mosque again. Christian attachments survived the Ottoman conversion, just as the Ottoman and Muslim heritage remained visible during the museum era. Today’s disagreement concerns access to a living place of worship and the presentation of the building’s long history. Its history involves successive religious uses, with current disagreements about worship and access.
Ram Janmabhoomi and the former Babri Masjid site in Ayodhya

The Indian city of Ayodhya is revered by many Hindus as the birthplace of Rama, the hero of the Ramayana and, in many traditions, an incarnation of Vishnu. The location known as Ram Janmabhoomi became the subject of a long dispute because the Babri Masjid, a mosque associated with the sixteenth-century Mughals, stood there until 1992. Hindu devotion to the location and the mosque’s historical existence are both well established. Neither fact by itself establishes which earlier buildings were erected or demolished on that exact site.
Tradition dates the Babri Masjid to the reign of Babur, often linking it with his commander Mir Baqi. The belief that builders destroyed a Rama temple to erect it gained increasing political importance during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Excavators identified traces of a substantial earlier non-Islamic building, but did not establish that a particular Rama temple was demolished specifically to make way for the mosque. The 2019 judgment of India’s Supreme Court considered the archaeology while distinguishing those findings from the legal questions of ownership and entitlement.
Twentieth-century actions changed who could use the contested site. In December 1949, idols of Rama were placed inside the mosque and access was restricted. Hindu nationalist movements subsequently mobilised for a temple on the location. On 6 December 1992, a crowd demolished the Babri Masjid unlawfully. Extensive violence followed, causing many deaths. This was the work of modern political mobilisation and a failure to prevent the mosque’s destruction, with consequences for people far beyond those involved. Those decisions and the violence that followed were the actions of modern political movements and authorities.
In November 2019, India’s Supreme Court awarded the disputed land to a trust for a Hindu temple, while ordering that five acres elsewhere be provided for a mosque. The court also condemned the placement of idols in 1949 and the demolition in 1992 as unlawful. The Ram Mandir was consecrated in January 2024 and is now used for Hindu worship. For Muslims, the destroyed Babri Masjid remains a central part of the site’s modern history even after the judicial decision.
At Ayodhya, the mosque was destroyed in 1992, and the disputed plot later became the site of a Hindu temple following a judicial settlement of the property dispute. The court’s decision should not be turned into archaeological confirmation of every claim about events in the medieval period. The long-standing Hindu belief in Rama’s birthplace must also remain part of the history.
The Mahabodhi Temple at Bodh Gaya

Bodh Gaya, in the Indian state of Bihar, is where Buddhist tradition places Siddhartha Gautama’s awakening beneath a sacred fig tree. From that enlightenment he became known as the Buddha, and pilgrims have travelled to the place for centuries. Its religious importance centres on the Buddha’s awakening rather than a tomb or a king’s sanctuary. The living Bodhi tree is revered as descending from the earlier tree, not as an archaeologically demonstrable survivor from Gautama’s lifetime.
The material remains record centuries of worship and rebuilding. The Mauryan emperor Ashoka is associated with a shrine of the third century BCE and a polished sandstone vajrasana, the ‘diamond throne’ marking the place of enlightenment. The high brick Mahabodhi temple is generally dated to the fifth or sixth century CE, although restoration and later additions complicate its visible appearance. The UNESCO World Heritage record documents early brick architecture, decorated railings, votive stupas and other structures clustered near the sacred tree. The complex grew over time rather than remaining exactly as it stood under Ashoka.
Control became contested as Buddhist establishments diminished in parts of northern India and Hindu ascetics came to occupy important roles at Bodh Gaya. A Shaivite mahant, or head of a religious establishment, exercised authority over the shrine and its property. In the nineteenth century Anagarika Dharmapala, a Buddhist reformer, sought greater Buddhist access and management, linking the campaign to wider Buddhist revival movements. At issue were representation, custody, income and administration of a pilgrimage centre. No one needed to deny the Buddha’s historical veneration there for those questions to become divisive.
The Bodh Gaya Temple Act of 1949 created an administrative committee including Hindus and Buddhists, with the chairmanship connected to local district government. Amendments later changed who could qualify as chair. Many Buddhists still disputed the division of authority and continued to call for Buddhist management. In 2025, a challenge to the 1949 framework reached India’s Supreme Court. The committee gives both communities representation, while the dispute over ultimate control continues.
For Buddhist pilgrims, prayer, meditation and circumambulation at Bodh Gaya commemorate the Buddha’s enlightenment. The history of Hindu involvement developed through other religious institutions and changing patterns of regional power. These histories meet at the same temple but should not be merged into an assumption that the Buddha simply belonged to modern Hinduism, or that Hindus and Buddhists have always approached the place with identical beliefs and rights.
Sri Pada, or Adam’s Peak, in Sri Lanka

Sri Pada rises steeply in central Sri Lanka. Buddhists often call it the Sacred Footprint, whereas the English-language name Adam’s Peak reflects another tradition attached to it. At the summit, a depression shaped like a footprint lies within a shrine. Archaeology does not identify it as an actual impression left by any sacred figure. Generations of pilgrims have valued the mark because of the religious meanings placed upon it.
Sri Lankan Buddhists associate the footprint with a visit by the Buddha, said to have left it as a blessing. The Mahavamsa, compiled many centuries after his supposed lifetime, recounts traditions about his journeys to the island. These stories are devotional accounts, not independently established travel records. The mountain has also been associated with the protective deity Saman and supported by rulers. Medieval inscriptions and records of pilgrimage confirm that reverence for the summit has a long history.
Among Hindu devotees, the footprint may be understood as Shiva’s, and Tamil names link the mountain to that deity. Muslim traditions identify it with Adam, who was said to have reached earth here after leaving paradise. Some Christians have connected the mark to Adam or to the apostle Thomas. The Sri Lankan nomination on UNESCO’s tentative list records the different associations, but provides no basis for assuming every community attended in equal numbers, performed the same rites or retained uninterrupted access throughout history.
Reaching the shrine takes considerable effort. Pilgrims ascend long stairways and steep paths, frequently travelling through the night so that they arrive in time for sunrise. Lamps, bells, prayers and offerings accompany the repeated climb. People from several religious backgrounds may follow the same route while understanding the footprint in entirely different ways. They take part in the same pilgrimage landscape while maintaining different accounts of the mark’s origin.
The coexistence of these interpretations should not be mistaken for evidence that relations among Sri Lanka’s religious communities have always been harmonious. Access, royal support and patterns of pilgrimage have changed, against a wider history that includes ethnic and religious tension. Buddhist, Hindu, Muslim and some Christian interpretations of the footprint have continued alongside changes in patronage and access.
The Western Wall and its prayer plaza in Jerusalem

The Western Wall of Jerusalem, sometimes called the Wailing Wall in older English accounts, is part of the retaining system supporting the Temple Mount. Large sections belong to the Herodian expansion of the Second Temple precinct, although it is not a surviving wall of the temple’s inner building. The wall became an important place for Jewish prayer and mourning because it stands near the lost sanctuary. Its stones reflect the construction of the platform; the temple structure destroyed by Rome in 70 CE has not survived above it.
The space around the Western Wall has undergone successive changes. Israel Antiquities Authority excavations record monumental masonry and drainage, followed by later building and use on the western side of the precinct. Roman, Byzantine and early Islamic phases are present in the archaeological sequence, along with Jewish and Muslim associations with the surrounding city. The excavations document centuries of activity between the temple’s destruction in 70 CE and the present day.
The large open prayer plaza was created recently. Israel captured East Jerusalem in June 1967, and the Maghrebi, or Moroccan, Quarter beside the wall was then demolished, displacing its Palestinian inhabitants. A 2023 reconstruction study of the quarter reconstructs the neighbourhood’s development and its destruction. Earlier streets and houses occupied much of the area now seen in photographs of the open square. The present plaza occupies ground that held an inhabited neighbourhood before its demolition in 1967.
Questions about worship at the wall also divide Jewish communities. Its main prayer area is administered according to Orthodox practice, with separate sections for men and women. Other Jewish groups have sought mixed-gender prayer and greater opportunity for women to read from the Torah. The disagreement concerns the religious rules of a space of exceptional Jewish importance. It is distinct from disputes between Judaism and Islam, though it unfolds within the same contested Jerusalem landscape.
Archaeology and visitors’ access have produced further conflict. A new exit from the Western Wall tunnels, opened near the Muslim Quarter in 1996, was followed by deadly clashes between Israeli forces and Palestinians. Israeli authorities described the work in terms of archaeological access and tourism. Palestinian opponents feared possible harm to the Muslim sanctuary and understood the project through the struggle over Jerusalem’s sovereignty. Research on archaeology and sanctity at the wall after 1967 also reveals disputes between Israeli institutions over whether the wall’s surroundings should be governed chiefly as a sacred precinct or as archaeological heritage.
The wall and the Temple Mount form parts of the same religious and physical setting; separating them entirely would distort Jerusalem’s geography. They are discussed individually because the wall has its own recent history of neighbourhood demolition, debates about Jewish prayer and arguments over excavation. Disagreements over the wall include disputes within Judaism over religious practice as well as conflicts between communities.
Why shared sacred ground can become disputed
Their histories differ in how religious authorities gained, shared or lost control. Hagia Sophia’s worship changed under governments with different religions and policies. At the Holy Sepulchre, Christian denominations negotiated a highly regulated division of space. Hebron’s shared sanctuary was partitioned amid modern occupation and mass violence. Sri Pada continues to gather differing readings of one footprint, while Bodh Gaya’s representative management has itself provoked objections. These differences become clear only when each site’s religious history and legal arrangements are considered.
Anthropologist Robert M. Hayden has described a pattern he calls “antagonistic tolerance” and “competitive sharing”. Writing in 2002 about South Asia and the Balkans, he argued that distinct groups may worship in or around a common shrine while competing over authority and prestige, and that political changes can expose unequal relationships. His account has influenced discussion of shared holy sites, though it is an interpretive model for certain situations. It does not establish that every shared shrine must eventually become the scene of violence.
Control of a sacred place often lies in practical decisions that acquire religious significance. Restricting an entrance determines who reaches a place of prayer. Restoration can change the allocation of denominational rights. An archaeological excavation may raise legal and political fears as well as historical questions. Knowing when the first building was erected does not resolve the claims over access, restoration or ownership. Beliefs, material remains, government authority and the history of agreements all need to be considered together.
The same site may be venerated by several communities while only some possess the authority to administer it or use it freely. Elsewhere, worshippers may continue their practices under rules fixed by another government or denomination. Its history includes the devotional practices of those communities and the political institutions that regulate access and use. Archaeological evidence can illuminate that past, but some claims remain matters of religious belief, and no description should quietly turn them into proven material facts.









Discussion
Comments