At the Battle of Marathon in 490 BC, an Athenian named Epizelus reportedly lost his sight while fighting the Persian army. Herodotus says no weapon struck him. Epizelus later described an enormous warrior in armour, with a beard that overshadowed his shield, passing him and killing the soldier at his side. He remained blind for the rest of his life. The story is frequently cited in discussions of psychological injury in ancient warfare.
The account has become part of a broader argument about ancient Greek and Roman soldiers. They fought at close quarters, saw companions killed, and sometimes spent long periods far from home on military campaigns. Whether such soldiers experienced what modern medicine calls post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is debated. The difficulty is that ancient writers seldom followed ordinary soldiers through the years after they served. Historians also disagree about what can be gained, or lost, by diagnosing people whose lives belonged to very different medical and cultural worlds.
Ancient accounts give abundant evidence of fear, grief, disturbed sleep and other suffering, but too little detail to establish PTSD as a particular condition. Greek, Mesopotamian and Roman accounts record unusual behaviour and distress, but each was composed for a purpose and within ideas about religion, character and illness unlike those used in modern psychiatry. A person can endure a traumatic event without meeting the diagnostic criteria for PTSD, and historical claims have to respect that difference.
What Would Count as Evidence of PTSD in Antiquity?
A clinical diagnosis of PTSD requires more than fear in battle or a painful memory. It may follow exposure to threatened death, serious injury or another traumatic experience, with symptoms that continue to disrupt a person’s life. Recurrent involuntary memories or nightmares, avoidance of reminders, changes in mood and thinking, and heightened responses to danger can form part of the condition. As the US National Institute of Mental Health explains, diagnosis requires a particular combination of symptoms lasting longer than a month. Warfare is one possible cause, but PTSD also occurs among people who have never been soldiers.
Ancient authors rarely supply the information needed to apply that definition. One report of a nightmare tells us nothing certain about months of avoidance, recurring memories or the person’s ability to live and work. Anger or reckless conduct likewise gives no secure explanation of its own cause. A historian must consider who wrote the account, when and why, and whether a different illness or literary convention offers another reading. No surviving ancient case provides the kind of complete clinical assessment needed to diagnose an individual veteran.
Epizelus at Marathon: Blindness, Battle and a Divine Apparition

Herodotus tells Epizelus’ story in Histories 6.117. He places the Athenian in the fighting at Marathon and remarks on his courage before recording the sudden blindness. Epizelus had apparently been struck by neither missile nor weapon. Instead, he said, an immense armoured figure had appeared and killed the man beside him. Herodotus treats it as an extraordinary occurrence, not a medical case history. He tells us nothing about Epizelus’ later nightmares, attempts to avoid reminders of the battle or state of mind after the loss of sight.
Modern interpretations have sometimes proposed a functional neurological symptom: a loss of bodily function for which the usual structural injury does not provide an adequate explanation. Severe distress can accompany such symptoms. That possibility makes Epizelus’ experience relevant to debates about reactions to combat, but it is not evidence that he had PTSD. There was no examination of his eyes or nervous system, no record of other symptoms and no means of ruling out an ophthalmic or neurological condition. Blindness alone is outside the defining groups of PTSD symptoms.
Herodotus wrote decades after Marathon, for readers familiar with stories of heroes or gods appearing during warfare. The figure Epizelus saw was not described as an ordinary Persian fighter who happened to frighten him. He passed one Athenian, killed another and left behind a story of apparent supernatural intervention. An ancient audience could reasonably have heard this as testimony to the participation of divine powers on the battlefield.
James C. Ford, in a 2025 reassessment of Epizelus, places particular weight on that religious background. He considers how Athenians commemorated Marathon, including the well-known painting of the battle in the Stoa Poikile, the Painted Stoa at Athens. The painting is lost, but later accounts attest to the public memory of the story and its central figure. Ford argues that the apparition is best approached through the Greek idea of divine epiphany, an appearance of a god or supernatural being to a mortal, before attempting any modern clinical interpretation.
Epizelus may have suffered psychologically from what he witnessed. The problem is that Herodotus gives us too little evidence to determine how. Owen Rees, in his 2020 study of Epizelus and modern PTSD arguments, likewise cautioned against selecting a few apparently familiar symptoms while leaving behind the rest of an ancient account. The episode tells us a great deal about the way Greeks remembered an extraordinary event at Marathon; it does not supply the medical history of a diagnosed patient.
Mesopotamian Tablets: Night Terrors and the Ghosts of the Dead

Scholars have also searched Mesopotamian medical texts for evidence of trauma. Cuneiform medical and diagnostic writings describe patients afraid during the night, disturbed by visions, unable to speak clearly or experiencing changes in thought and conduct. Scribes transmitted these formulations across long periods, and healers sometimes explained such conditions through gods, ghosts and other supernatural agents. In that framework, a ghost might be considered the source of an illness in its own right, rather than a symbolic memory of something terrible that had happened earlier.
In 2014, psychiatrists Walid Khalid Abdul-Hamid and Jamie Hacker Hughes argued that some Assyrian-period descriptions resembled symptoms of PTSD. Their article Nothing New Under the Sun brought together references to disturbed sleep, depressive feelings and visions of the dead, suggesting that some sufferers might have been soldiers haunted by enemies they had killed. If correct, the reading would place written descriptions of combat-related distress centuries before Herodotus.
The texts do not reliably identify their patients as soldiers returning from war. Many passages are diagnostic descriptions rather than personal testimonies. They do not consistently establish that the patient fought in a war, killed anyone or began experiencing symptoms after military service. A vision of a dead person is also not automatically a flashback. Mesopotamian explanations involving ghosts could encompass illnesses that modern physicians would separate, while confusion, altered awareness, impaired speech and fear are compatible with several kinds of condition.
Research on epilepsy and other neurological conditions in Mesopotamian medicine has raised alternative explanations. A critical discussion of the Assyrian PTSD interpretation compares the translated descriptions with texts concerning seizures and finds no secure basis for attributing them specifically to wartime trauma. Popular retellings sometimes cite a supposed Assyrian cycle of three years divided among military service, public works and time at home. Even if repeated, that claim cannot establish whether the patients in particular medical tablets had been soldiers or whether their illnesses began after campaigning.
In a 2026 review of trauma symptoms across four millennia, Walter Paganin considered descriptions that resemble features of trauma-related illness in Mesopotamian and later sources. His use of modern categories allows comparison across time, without implying that an ancient individual received an equivalent diagnosis. The tablets still preserve evidence of how Mesopotamian healers described and treated suffering. Whether any of those passages securely records combat-related PTSD is still disputed.
What Roman Soldiers Actually Said About Fear

Roman narratives provide more direct accounts of soldiers’ fears in battle. Men could remain in the army for years, covering considerable distances and facing siege operations, raids, battles and civil wars. Roman fighting involved swords, javelins, spears and missiles; opponents might deploy cavalry, slings and even war elephants. Soldiers could kill close at hand, witness serious wounds and fear for their own lives. Explosive weapons were not required for combat to be terrifying. The harder question is what happened to those men emotionally once they were away from danger.
Julius Caesar acknowledged fear among his troops during the Gallic campaigns. In Gallic War 1.39, describing his campaign against the German leader Ariovistus in 58 BC, he says alarming stories circulated through his army until some officers sought reasons to withdraw and others wept or tried to conceal their panic. Caesar answered with a speech intended to restore confidence. Even experienced Roman soldiers could panic before a fight. Caesar’s account tells us nothing about whether those men suffered persistent symptoms after combat.
An account of Caesar’s North African campaign in 46 BC offers a related example. The author of African War 72 describes anxiety over enemy elephants and says Caesar brought elephants from Italy for his soldiers to examine. The men could learn where to strike, while their horses became familiar with the animals’ movements and noise. The exercise prepared soldiers and horses for an unfamiliar enemy weapon. The text is part of the Caesarian corpus, the collection of writings associated with Caesar’s campaigns, but Caesar himself did not write it.
Caesar’s campaign narratives concentrated on command decisions and military conduct, leaving the private aftermath of fighting largely unrecorded. Caesar had reasons to show his men recovering discipline through his decisions, and most Roman military histories emphasise obedience, courage and performance in battle. They rarely pursue a common soldier into his civilian years to learn whether a recurring dream or painful memory followed him home. Aislinn Melchior makes this evidential gap central to her 2011 study of Roman soldiers and PTSD. Fear is well represented in the literary record; the lasting private effects of combat are not.
Roman Veterans, Nightmares and Mental Illness
Some Roman biographies preserve accounts of longer-lasting mental suffering. In Plutarch’s Life of Marius 45, Gaius Marius is described near the end of his life in 86 BC as haunted by frightening dreams, sleeplessness and memories of flight and danger. He reportedly drank heavily to obtain sleep while fearing the return of his political rival Sulla. Some of these details resemble trauma-related distress. Yet Marius was also facing political danger, illness, old age and renewed civil conflict. Plutarch wrote his biography long after the events and supplies no basis for a clinical diagnosis.
Appian’s Civil Wars 5.49 describes another disturbing death. In the aftermath of the siege of Perusia in 40 BC, Cestius, a man who had served earlier in Macedonia and taken the name Macedonicus, burned his house and died inside it. Appian describes him as mentally disturbed. His former military service makes a trauma explanation conceivable, but the historian provides neither a symptom history nor evidence connecting the act to earlier fighting. The episode took place as a city faced devastation after civil war. It shows that a Roman-period writer recognised mental disturbance, while telling us nothing dependable about the frequency of PTSD among veterans.
Roman jurists recognised that illness, insanity, despair or severe pain could influence a soldier’s behaviour when discussing military offences. A ruling associated with Emperor Hadrian, preserved as Digest 49.16.6.7, distinguishes motives or circumstances surrounding attempted suicide when assigning punishment. Roman military authorities could therefore regard a person’s mental state as relevant, even if they possessed no account of a modern trauma syndrome. Korneel Van Lommel has similarly argued that juristic and other Roman evidence reflects recognition of mental impairment in military life.
Inscriptions offer details that literature often leaves out: a veteran’s unit, rank, home region, length of service and sometimes his position in the community after discharge. Some men are commemorated for notable civilian careers. Such inscriptions seldom tell us about intrusive memories, repeated nightmares or the emotional cost of killing. Holding office after service would not rule out private distress, and an inscription praising courage cannot tell us whether its subject suffered psychologically. The absence of such evidence in a memorial cannot rule out symptoms.
Could Roman Helmets and Weapons Have Changed the Risk?

Traumatic brain injury has also entered the debate over ancient PTSD. Charles Hoge and colleagues studied 2,525 US infantry soldiers several months after their return from Iraq in 2008. The New England Journal of Medicine study found PTSD criteria met by 43.9 percent of those reporting injury with loss of consciousness, 27.3 percent reporting altered mental status, 16.2 percent with other injuries and 9.1 percent reporting no injury. Those figures show an association between different categories of injury and PTSD in the population studied. They are not rates for soldiers in every conflict, nor do they establish concussion as the sole cause of PTSD.
Melchior drew on this work in considering whether Roman warfare exposed soldiers to a different pattern of risk. Romans had no improvised explosive devices or artillery shells, and their helmets offered some protection against impacts to the head. She suggested that concussive injuries might have been less frequent than in modern blast-heavy conflicts. Melchior was suggesting a possible difference in risk, since ancient rates of brain injury cannot be calculated. Stones, sling missiles, collapsing masonry and ordinary weapons could all produce blunt trauma. We lack the Roman medical records needed for any reliable comparison.
PTSD also occurs without concussion. Even the 2008 study found qualifying symptoms among soldiers with injuries other than head trauma and among those reporting no injury. Captivity, the prospect of death and witnessing a companion killed are potentially traumatic experiences without any blow to the skull. The equipment of an ancient army therefore cannot settle the question of PTSD. They may have altered certain risks, but no surviving evidence allows a numerical comparison of PTSD prevalence between ancient armies and modern ones.
Why Historians Disagree About Ancient Combat Trauma
Much of the debate turns on whether modern psychological categories can be applied across very different cultures. A universalist approach starts from the likelihood that people in different centuries shared broadly similar capacities for fear, grief, stress and memory. That makes comparisons between ancient battle experiences and later trauma reasonable questions. In Achilles in Vietnam (1994), psychiatrist Jonathan Shay read Homer’s Iliad alongside accounts from American veterans, drawing on the epic to help patients articulate experiences of rage, betrayal and loss. His use of the poem had an important therapeutic purpose.
Lawrence Tritle, a classicist and Vietnam veteran, made a related case in From Melos to My Lai (2000). One of his examples was Clearchus, the Spartan commander whom Xenophon describes in Anabasis 2.6 as particularly devoted to war. Tritle suggested that this attraction to fighting might relate to combat trauma. Melchior objected that Xenophon praised Clearchus as an active, competent commander without describing symptoms of psychological illness. Enjoying war, whatever it reveals about a man’s character, does not establish unwanted memories, avoidance or persistent distress.
Greeks and Romans could have suffered psychological injuries while interpreting those experiences through categories unfamiliar to modern medicine. A Greek narrative might describe a divine appearance on the battlefield; a Mesopotamian healer might blame a ghost; a Roman historian might explain conduct in terms of discipline, honour or ambition. Automatically recasting each account as PTSD risks obscuring what those explanations meant to their original audiences.
Comparisons with modern veterans can clarify some questions about ancient warfare, provided their limits are recognised. A chapter on battle trauma in ancient Greece published in 2021 compares ancient combatants with modern veterans, paying particular attention to men injured in fighting and to what came afterwards. Ford’s 2025 treatment of Epizelus and Rees’s earlier work instead insist that the religious and historical setting must lead the interpretation of Herodotus’ story. The disagreement concerns what the evidence permits a comparison to establish, rather than whether violence could be frightening.
Later Byzantine military writing supplies another kind of evidence. In a 2016 study, psychiatrist Pavlos Ntafoulis examined Middle Byzantine military writings and found accounts of exhaustion, homesickness, acute combat stress and soldiers unable to move or speak in battle. Commanders’ responses ranged from encouragement to severe discipline, but the study reported no clear description of PTSD. The texts are later than the Roman Republic and cannot simply be transferred backwards. They do show that a source may record recognisable mental strain while leaving out the prolonged symptom history required for a modern diagnosis.
Some discussions claim that Romans were protected from trauma because executions, warfare and gladiatorial shows made violent death familiar. Roman social expectations were certainly different from many modern ones, and ideas about courage and shame affected how people expressed fear. Familiarity, however, cannot be equated with immunity. Nor can it prove that ancient suffering took exactly the same form as modern distress. The surrounding culture may shape what people reveal and how they explain it, while individual vulnerability remains impossible to measure from the surviving accounts.
So, Did Ancient Soldiers Have PTSD?
Greek stories, Mesopotamian tablets and Roman historical and legal writing leave little doubt that warfare could bring fear, grief and considerable mental suffering. Herodotus preserved the sudden blindness of Epizelus; cuneiform texts described troubled nights and altered behaviour; Roman writers recorded panic, disturbing dreams and despair. Jurists even considered mental illness when assessing certain military offences. Yet none of these records supplies a securely diagnosed ancient case of PTSD. Their authors did not follow all the symptoms over time, and several celebrated examples allow other explanations.
Ancient soldiers may well have experienced reactions resembling what modern medicine calls PTSD. The sources do not tell us how many did, whether a named individual would meet current diagnostic criteria or how rates compared with those of later armies. They still offer material for a history of combat-related distress, provided ancient descriptions are read on their own terms.









Discussion
Comments