In the middle of the third century BCE, Eratosthenes of Cyrene estimated the Earth’s circumference from observations made in Egypt. Working in Alexandria, the Greek-speaking capital of Egypt, he combined observations of the Sun at two cities with a distance measured on the ground. Ancient writers preserve two figures for his result: 250,000 stades in one account and 252,000 in several others. A stade was an ancient unit of length.
The summer solstice provided the crucial observation. At Syene, near present-day Aswan in southern Egypt, the midday Sun was said to stand almost directly overhead. At Alexandria, farther north, the Sun remained at an angle to the vertical. Provided the cities were aligned north to south, the difference in angle would give the proportion of the Earth’s circumference between them. Eratosthenes could then use the distance between the cities to calculate the distance around the entire sphere.
Popular retellings credit Eratosthenes with discovering that the Earth was round by planting a stick in the ground. Greek thinkers already had arguments for a spherical Earth, and Eratosthenes’ account of his own work is lost. His method survives through later authors, whose reported totals do not entirely agree. We can follow the geometry in detail, but questions remain about the observations, units and eventual accuracy of the measurement.
Eratosthenes and the scholars of Alexandria

Eratosthenes was born around 276 BCE in Cyrene, a Greek city on the North African coast in modern Libya. After studying in the Greek intellectual world, he entered the service of the Ptolemies, the Macedonian dynasty established in Egypt after Alexander the Great. Under Ptolemy III, Alexandria supported a major royal library and drew scholars who collected texts and pursued research. Eratosthenes eventually directed the library. Neither the exact date of his appointment nor the date of his Earth measurement is securely established.
Eratosthenes also worked in several other fields. He wrote poetry and literary criticism, studied mathematics and astronomy, and worked to describe the inhabited world systematically. The sieve used to identify prime numbers is associated with his name, as is the mathematical investigation of geographical problems. A later biographical tradition nicknamed him “Beta,” the second letter of the Greek alphabet, on the allegation that he ranked second in many subjects. That remark is better evidence of ancient attitudes toward scholarly reputation than a measure of his ability.
Alexandria offered access to geographical information from the Nile valley. Merchants, officials and other travellers moved through Ptolemaic Egypt, comparing distances between settlements and observing seasonal conditions. Eratosthenes could bring geographical knowledge from Egypt into contact with the techniques of Greek mathematical astronomy. The distance between two places, combined with observations of the Sun, could supply the figures for a calculation covering the whole Earth.
Eratosthenes was also part of an active mathematical community. Archimedes of Syracuse addressed The Method to him, evidence that the two scholars were in intellectual contact. His combination of mathematical and geographical interests helps explain why he treated the dimensions of the inhabited world as a problem for astronomy and geometry, supported by the information travellers could supply.
The Greeks already knew the Earth was spherical

Greek mathematicians had been discussing the Earth’s spherical shape for generations. More than a century before Eratosthenes, Aristotle defended it in On the Heavens, book 2, chapter 14. During lunar eclipses, he observed, the Earth casts a curved-edged shadow on the Moon. He also noted that different stars come into view as someone travels north or south. Both observations fit a curved surface. Aristotle mentioned mathematicians who put the Earth’s circumference at 400,000 stades, although he gave no account of their method.
In Archimedes’ Sand-Reckoner, Archimedes likewise reported that some people had tried to demonstrate a circumference of about 300,000 stades. Writing in the third century BCE, he then used three million stades as an intentionally generous upper bound for the size of the Earth. His aim was to show how numbers could express the quantity of sand needed to fill a vast space. The larger figure did not represent a new geographical survey.
Eratosthenes inherited a problem that earlier mathematicians had already considered. They wanted to determine how large the spherical Earth was. In principle, knowing the length of a stretch of its surface and the angle that stretch made at the centre would reveal the entire circumference. A reliable result depended on finding an angular difference and a matching ground distance.
He applied comparable mathematical reasoning to the location of places across the inhabited world. He organised the inhabited world through major east-west parallels and north-south lines. Those lines supplied a systematic structure for mapping, although all surviving reconstructions of his geographical work are modern assemblies of fragments, many quoted by Strabo. No original map drawn by Eratosthenes has survived.
Why Syene and Alexandria mattered
Syene lay near the Nile’s first cataract and the southern edge of Ptolemaic Egypt. It was associated with an unusual observation at midsummer: around noon on the summer solstice, the Sun rose almost directly overhead. A standing post then cast scarcely any visible shadow, and sunlight could penetrate a deep well. In Alexandria, on the Mediterranean coast farther north, an upright object continued to cast a measurable shadow at the same time of year.
The well appears in ancient accounts, although none shows Eratosthenes observing it in person. Pliny the Elder, Natural History 2.183 describes a well at Syene constructed to examine the overhead Sun. Strabo, Geography 17.1.48 also writes about a solstice well and the sunlight reaching its water. These accounts establish the existence of the tradition, not a personal visit by Eratosthenes. In the surviving mathematical explanation, the well illustrates the Sun’s position at Syene; it is not essential measuring equipment.
The actual geography complicates the ideal picture. Alexandria is near 31.2 degrees north latitude, while Syene is near 24.1 degrees, a difference of about 7.1 degrees. Syene is also roughly three degrees of longitude east of Alexandria. It therefore lies southeast, rather than directly south, of the northern city. For a meridian-based calculation, their separation needs to be measured or corrected as a north-south arc, rather than as a route between any two points.
Another approximation concerns the Sun itself. In Eratosthenes’ day the Tropic of Cancer, the northernmost latitude at which the Sun can stand directly overhead, was slightly south of Syene. Even at the solstice the Sun there would have been a little short of the zenith, the point immediately overhead. An ancient report of no shadow therefore describes a close approximation, not perfectly aligned modern coordinates.
The observed difference in the Sun’s angle from the vertical at Alexandria and Syene supplied the crucial measurement. Alexandria’s shadow provided an angle, while the Sun at Syene was treated as virtually vertical. Comparing those observations made it possible to relate a known stretch of Egypt to a portion of the Earth’s circumference.
The shadow angle: one-fiftieth of a circle

Our fullest surviving explanation comes from Cleomedes, an astronomer who lived centuries after Eratosthenes. In On the Circular Motions of the Heavenly Bodies, Cleomedes lays out the assumptions and the geometric proof. At Alexandria he describes a pointer inside a bowl-shaped sundial whose shadow covered one-fiftieth of a circle. Since a circle has 360 degrees, the angle was 7.2 degrees, or seven degrees and twelve minutes.
A gnomon is an upright pointer whose shadow shows the direction of the Sun. On a level surface, a vertical pointer and its shadow form a right-angled triangle. The tangent of the angle between the Sun’s rays and the vertical is the shadow length divided by the pointer’s height. Another possibility is a hemispherical sundial or skaphe, whose curved surface registers the shadow as an arc. Both arrangements express the angle geometrically, though Cleomedes describes a bowl rather than a simple stick on flat ground.
In Cleomedes’ account, the midday Sun at Alexandria stood 7.2 degrees from the vertical on the solstice, while at Syene it was treated as overhead. Those two local verticals point in different directions. On a spherical Earth, a vertical line at each location follows the direction of the radius between the surface and the planet’s centre. The angle between the radii is what Eratosthenes needed to find.
Because the Sun is so far away, its rays at the two Egyptian cities can be treated as parallel. Draw a line from each city to the Earth’s centre. The angle separating those lines equals the difference between the directions of the Sun relative to the two local verticals. Under these ideal conditions, the 7.2-degree angle observed in the sky is also the central angle subtended by the arc between the cities.
Fifty angles of 7.2 degrees make a complete 360-degree circle. The corresponding stretch of the Earth’s surface between Syene and Alexandria must therefore cover one-fiftieth of its circumference. The shadow measurement supplied the proportion. Eratosthenes still needed to know how much ground lay along that one-fiftieth.
The 5,000-stade distance and the calculation
Cleomedes supplies a figure of 5,000 stades for the distance between the cities. A stade varied in length across ancient places and periods. The estimate may have come from geographical or administrative records kept in Egypt, although Cleomedes does not identify a surveyor or describe the procedure. Stories of Eratosthenes hiring men to count their steps beside the Nile resemble forms of ancient distance measurement. No surviving account of his calculation establishes that he actually arranged such an expedition.
The next step was multiplication. A surface arc of 5,000 stades, if it represents one-fiftieth of a full circle, gives a circumference of 5,000 multiplied by fifty, or 250,000 stades. One degree of latitude would then amount to approximately 694.4 stades. The arithmetic required no elaborate instrument. Everything depends on how accurately the angle and the ground distance were obtained, and on whether they refer to the same arc.
Cleomedes’ geometry treats the 5,000 stades as a north-south distance along a meridian. A road or the winding Nile could give a different length, even if it connected the same cities. Rounding the angular difference would introduce another error: a change of only a few tenths of a degree could shift the calculated circumference by several percent. Neither issue disappears merely because the final multiplication is straightforward.
The calculation could be checked because its assumptions were explicit. It connected named locations, solar observations, an angle and a surface distance through a known geometric proportion. A later geographer could question any one of those measurements and still use the same method to improve the estimate.
Was the instrument really just a stick?

The familiar classroom demonstration uses a stick, whereas Cleomedes describes a curved instrument. The shadow moved across a bowl-shaped sundial, suggesting a skaphe with a pointer at the centre of its hemispherical surface. Such instruments were familiar in Greek astronomical practice. We do not know the exact instrument Eratosthenes used, how large it was or the procedure that produced the recorded angle.
An upright rod requires careful handling if its shadow is to yield a useful result. The surface must be level, the rod truly vertical and the reading taken at local solar noon, when the Sun is highest. Because the Sun appears as a disc about half a degree across, a shadow has no perfectly sharp edge. A curved sundial makes the angle easier to register, but does not eliminate the difficulties of observation.
Cleomedes was presenting a geometric demonstration; he may have simplified conditions that were more complicated in Eratosthenes’ original work. Newlyn Walkup, a historian of mathematics writing for the Mathematical Association of America, notes that we cannot distinguish with certainty Eratosthenes’ own observations from information he received. Eratosthenes combined the reported distances and solar angles in a single geometric argument. No independent source records him personally placing a rod in the ground.
Why ancient writers give 250,000 and 252,000 stades
Ancient authors give two different totals. Cleomedes’ calculation arrives at 250,000 stades, whereas Strabo, Geography 2.5.7 gives Eratosthenes a circumference of 252,000 stades. Other ancient writers also report the larger number. The difference is less than one percent, but the loss of Eratosthenes’ original treatise prevents us from establishing why the figures diverge.
One explanation for the figure of 252,000 stades is that it simplified geographical arithmetic. Divide it by 360 and the result is exactly 700 stades for each degree. It can also be divided neatly into sixty parts, a useful convention in ancient mathematical astronomy. A total of 250,000 would instead give a recurring fraction when divided into degrees. That convenient division would make calculations of latitude, distance and the inhabited world easier.
Christián Carlos Carman and James Evans proposed another interpretation in their 2015 paper “The Two Earths of Eratosthenes”, published in Isis. They suggest that 250,000 may have been a lower bound found by treating sunlight as parallel, while a calculation that allowed for a finite solar distance, also attributed to Eratosthenes, would produce a value close to 252,000. Under this interpretation, the two figures would give lower and upper bounds for the circumference.
Carman and Evans’ explanation is a modern reconstruction, not Eratosthenes’ surviving account. Its plausibility depends on the testimony about the Sun’s distance and on how the scholar’s reasoning is reconstructed. We cannot tell whether he revised a calculation, offered two bounds, or had a more complex argument simplified by later authors. Regardless of its origin, 252,000 stades became widely used in later Greek and Roman geography.
How close was Eratosthenes to the modern circumference?
Today the Earth’s circumference is measured at about 40,075 kilometres around the equator and 40,008 kilometres along a meridian running north to south. The figures differ because the planet is slightly flattened at its poles. Since Eratosthenes’ approach used a north-south arc, the meridional circumference is the appropriate comparison. Converting his answer into kilometres, however, first requires a decision about the ancient stade’s length.
One proposed Egyptian stade measures 157.5 metres. On that assumption, a total of 250,000 stades equals 39,375 kilometres, about 1.6 percent below the present meridional figure. For 252,000 stades the conversion gives 39,690 kilometres, less than one percent below it. These results explain why Eratosthenes is so often credited with an estimate extremely close to modern measurements.
The conversion remains disputed. We cannot securely assume that every stade in the ancient testimony measured 157.5 metres. If Eratosthenes used a stade of approximately 185 metres, then 250,000 stades would equal 46,250 kilometres, about sixteen percent above the modern meridional circumference. The Mathematical Association of America’s discussion of ancient stade lengths explains the uncertainty surrounding the unit. Since the stade varied, scholars disagree about the exact modern value to attach to his total.
A percentage error calculated from the ancient figure is therefore conditional on the chosen unit. Eratosthenes used sound geometry to arrive at a result on the right scale for the Earth. The widespread assertion that he was “within two percent” can be justified under a particular stade conversion, but is not a securely established measure of the accuracy of his original work.
Several uncertainties remain even after selecting a conversion. Syene stood slightly north of the summer tropic, the two cities differed in longitude, and the reported travel distance may not have described the meridian arc required by the calculation. Some errors might have offset others. A numerical result close to today’s circumference would not, by itself, prove that each ancient observation was equally accurate.
The lost book and the limits of the evidence

Eratosthenes apparently presented his investigation in a book called On the Measurement of the Earth. That treatise is lost, although Hero of Alexandria, a later mathematician, referred to it by title. The reference confirms that the measurement circulated as a distinct mathematical investigation. It cannot tell us how much of Eratosthenes’ reasoning Cleomedes later reproduced or simplified.
Even Cleomedes’ date is debated, though he certainly wrote long after Eratosthenes. His text provides a coherent geometrical explanation and may condense an account that was more detailed. Strabo, Pliny and other authors supply additional numbers and observations, often without identifying the material they relied on. Their testimony can be compared, but it cannot replace the lost original.
The missing treatise is part of a wider loss. Eratosthenes’ geographical writing brought together accounts of places and routes extending from the Mediterranean across Asia and Africa. His studies of astronomical quantities and the tilt of the Earth likewise concerned the world’s physical dimensions. Later scholars read and debated those works. Most of what we know now survives in their quotations and reports rather than Eratosthenes’ own books.
Pictures of the Library of Alexandria sometimes used to accompany this story are modern reconstructions. Ptolemaic patronage of substantial collections and scholarly work is well attested, but no surviving depiction identifies the actual room where Eratosthenes worked. The calculation survives in written testimony, while Alexandria’s scholarly institutions provide its historical setting.
What later geographers did with his measurement
Later mathematical geographers used Eratosthenes’ circumference as a starting point for further calculations and criticism. Hipparchus, working in the second century BCE, criticised methods of geographical mapping while using astronomy to determine locations more accurately. Strabo describes his engagement with the circumference of 252,000 stades. Once a circumference was accepted, an angular difference in latitude could be converted into a ground distance, or a distance into degrees. The assumed size of the Earth thus shaped the grid on which geographical maps depended.
Posidonius, a later philosopher and geographer, attempted a different calculation using the bright southern star Canopus. He considered how high the star appeared above the horizon at Rhodes and Alexandria to estimate the north-south separation. Cleomedes transmits a result of 240,000 stades, based on a 5,000-stade distance and an angle equal to one-forty-eighth of a circle. Strabo also attributes a result of 180,000 stades to Posidonius. Because the relationship between these totals is disputed, neither can be treated as the one settled Posidonian estimate that replaced Eratosthenes’ result.
Claudius Ptolemy, writing in the second century CE, worked with a circumference of 180,000 stades. His Geography set out latitude and longitude for thousands of places, but its representation of the inhabited world was stretched in ways that later mapmakers struggled to reconcile with known distances. Ptolemy’s smaller Earth was one possible cause. Mistakes in inherited travel accounts and coordinates also affected the map.
The causes of these distortions remain under discussion. In a 2014 Max Planck Institute preprint, Irina Tupikova argued that the smaller circumference could account for much of Ptolemy’s distortion, provided the stadia being compared had similar lengths. Dmitry Shcheglov’s 2016 study in Isis argued against attributing the problem to one cause and stressed the complexity of the underlying geographical information. Reconstructing Ptolemy’s figures is difficult when both the original distances and the units used to measure them remain uncertain.
The calculation belongs to Greek astronomy as well as geography. Scholars were already using the apparent motions of the heavens to consider the Earth’s place in the cosmos. Aristarchus of Samos, an earlier astronomer, had even proposed that the Earth orbited the Sun. That was a separate question from the size of the planet. Eratosthenes’ geometry works whether one assumes the Earth or the Sun is moving, since the measurement depends on sunlight, angles and a spherical surface.
The enduring achievement
Students today can follow the same argument with a vertical rod, a level surface and a clock, provided they also have a second observation at a different latitude and a reliable distance between the sites. Divide a full 360-degree circle by the angular separation, then multiply the ground distance by that factor. Instruments and satellites now allow far more precise measurement of the Earth’s shape, but the relationship between surface distances and angular differences remains fundamental to geodesy, the science of measuring the planet.
Eratosthenes died at Alexandria around 194 BCE. A later biographical account attributes his death to a decision to stop eating after losing his eyesight, but the circumstances cannot be independently confirmed. His writings disappeared over time, leaving later scholars to transmit the celebrated measurement. They did not preserve the details of his instrument, how the 5,000-stade distance was obtained or why two totals circulated.
The surviving testimony still allows the geometry to be reconstructed. At Alexandria the Sun cast a measurable shadow; at Syene it was regarded as nearly overhead. The difference in solar angles, together with the measured distance, gave him the two quantities he needed. Eratosthenes used the geometry of a sphere to join the two and calculate a circumference that later scholars could test, question and refine.









Discussion
Comments