Between 41 and 238 CE, ten Roman emperors were killed by men whose positions normally required them to protect the ruler. Some assassins were palace employees familiar with the emperor’s private rooms. Others served in his guard or belonged to armies stationed far from Rome. Their proximity to the emperor made protection possible and gave them the opportunity to kill him when their loyalties changed.

Several of these murders involved the Praetorian Guard, established under Augustus to protect the emperor in and around the capital. Its officers managed access to the ruler, and its armed men could defend the palace or take control of it. Its officers and soldiers did not always share the same political interests. Among the killers discussed here were palace freedmen, a wrestling attendant, centurions serving a rival emperor and soldiers on the frontier.

Their grievances varied considerably. Caligula had humiliated an officer, Galba failed to meet troops’ expectations of payment, Geta was eliminated in a family struggle, and Maximinus died when a siege turned against his own army. Hostile ancient historians have also shaped much of what we know about these deaths, and their accounts sometimes conflict. These ten cases are a selection rather than a complete list of emperors who met violent ends. Each shows a different way the succession could be decided in an empire without a universally binding rule of inheritance.

The Praetorians were based close enough to the government to intervene directly. Their fortified camp, the Castra Praetoria, was built under Tiberius in the first century CE; sections of its walls still survive in the modern city. An emperor relied on these troops to keep other armed men away from him, while the same proximity placed considerable power in their hands. The closeness of the guards to the emperor made a sudden change of allegiance especially dangerous.

1. Caligula: A Praetorian Officer Takes Revenge (41 CE)

Claudius is discovered behind a curtain after Caligula's assassination inside the imperial palace
A Roman Emperor: 41 AD, Lawrence Alma-Tadema, 1871. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

On 24 January 41 CE, the emperor Gaius, commonly called Caligula, was attacked by conspirators led in part by Cassius Chaerea, a tribune of the Praetorian Guard. Chaerea had served the emperor’s father, Germanicus, and could approach Gaius through his military duties. In his biography of the emperor, Suetonius describes how Caligula mocked the officer by issuing sexually suggestive watchwords whenever he asked for the daily password. Suetonius treats the repeated humiliation as a personal grievance behind the killing, although the conspiracy involved more than Chaerea’s anger alone.

By the end of 40 CE, senators and members of the imperial household had reason to fear Caligula’s punishments. Surviving accounts describe executions and accusations that brought men close to him into danger. Exactly who knew of the plot in advance is difficult to establish, as Anthony Barrett and John Yardley’s examination of the surviving evidence explains. Chaerea and another tribune, Cornelius Sabinus, participated directly, but the assassination should not be understood as a decision made by the Praetorians collectively.

During games on the Palatine Hill, Caligula left the performances and entered a narrow passage beneath the palace buildings. The attackers used that moment to strike before loyal attendants could form a defense. Ancient writers disagree about who dealt which blow and in what order. Caligula’s wife Caesonia and their young daughter were also killed. Their deaths suggest an effort by at least some participants to prevent the family from regaining power, though responsibility for those murders and the exact intentions behind them remain disputed.

Removing Caligula did not give the conspirators control of the succession. Some senators considered reviving republican government, but Praetorians discovered his uncle Claudius in the palace and took him to their camp, where he was acclaimed emperor. Chaerea and his fellow assassins could not compel the rest of the guard to accept their plans. Claudius assumed power and had Chaerea executed. Claudius’s accession depended on the armed men who rallied to him immediately after the killing.

2. Galba: The Guard Backs a Better Candidate (69 CE)

Galba appears on horseback with a beheading scene behind him, evoking his murder after losing soldiers
Galba from Roman Emperors on Horseback, Adriaen Collaert, ca. 1587. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

When Nero lost the throne and killed himself in 68 CE, Galba, the elderly governor of Hispania Tarraconensis, emerged as his successor. His standing rested on administrative experience and a reputation for strict discipline, but also on alliances made during Nero’s collapse. Men of the Praetorian Guard had expected a reward for helping the new ruler. Galba refused to meet the promised terms and further damaged his position by alienating officers through dismissals and suspicion.

The expected payment was a donative, a customary reward to soldiers on a new emperor’s accession. Soldiers who swore allegiance and sometimes fought to secure a new emperor’s throne expected a payment in recognition of their service. Suetonius records Galba saying that he recruited soldiers rather than purchased them. He may indeed have believed such payments undermined discipline, although ancient biographies often preserve pointed sayings because they neatly explain a ruler’s fate. In practice, the refusal left the men who had helped raise him to power feeling cheated.

By January 69 CE, legions on the Rhine were already proclaiming Vitellius instead of Galba. Inside Rome, Marcus Salvius Otho saw another opportunity. Although he had supported Galba, he was passed over when the emperor adopted Lucius Calpurnius Piso Licinianus as heir. Otho sought backing among unhappy Praetorians. On 15 January they acclaimed him, and troops advanced on Galba while he was still receiving confused and contradictory reports of the revolt.

The soldiers killed Galba near the Lacus Curtius in the Roman Forum, the city’s central public space. Tacitus’ account in Histories 1 describes conflicting rumors, advice that pulled the emperor in different directions and an escort that dispersed. Tacitus preserves differing versions of Galba’s last words and cannot establish which soldier delivered the fatal blow. Piso was also found and killed. Otho had removed the named successor within Rome, but Vitellius and the Rhine armies still posed a military challenge from outside Italy.

Nero’s removal had already established how little senatorial acceptance could matter once the armies abandoned an emperor. Galba’s assassination demonstrated that the same crisis could erupt at the center of Rome. During the Year of the Four Emperors in 69 CE, Otho, Vitellius and eventually Vespasian competed for rule. A dynasty or Senate decree alone could no longer determine who held the throne when armies were prepared to back rival candidates.

Advertisements

3. Domitian: The Assassins Enter the Emperor's Room (96 CE)

Domitian appears on horseback with his stabbing death shown nearby, linking palace conspiracy to imperial rule
Domitian from Roman Emperors on Horseback, Adriaen Collaert, ca. 1587 to 1589. Source: The Met.

Domitian’s reign lasted from 81 to 96 CE. As Vespasian’s younger son and Titus’s successor, he continued the Flavian dynasty founded after the civil war of 69. He closely supervised the administration and frontier defenses, but relations with parts of the senatorial aristocracy worsened. Trials, executions and allegations of conspiracy left some officials serving near him unsure of their safety. By September 96, men inside the imperial household had joined a plot to kill him.

Stephanus, who was connected with Domitilla’s household, carried out the initial attack. According to Suetonius, Domitian 17, he bandaged an apparently injured arm and concealed a dagger beneath the wrapping. He obtained an audience by saying he had evidence of a plot. Domitian’s concern about conspiracies helped Stephanus approach him: an emperor anxious to uncover his enemies had a reason to admit someone claiming to bring urgent intelligence.

The first stab wounded Domitian without killing him. He fought Stephanus and tried to reach a dagger customarily kept beneath his pillow, but Suetonius says the weapon’s blade had been taken away. Other household personnel then joined the assault, among them a freedman linked with the chamberlain Parthenius. Cassius Dio’s account likewise connects Parthenius with the plot, though the accounts differ in their details. The emperor died in his private chambers on 18 September 96 CE.

Nerva, an elderly senator without a direct biological heir, became emperor after Domitian’s death. Senators condemned Domitian’s memory and welcomed the change, but some troops did not share their enthusiasm. Praetorians subsequently demanded that the killers be punished, and Nerva had to comply. The plot had succeeded because a small group of insiders could reach the emperor. That gave its organizers no corresponding ability to guarantee their own safety under his successor.

4. Commodus: Poison Fails, and an Attendant Finishes the Job (192 CE)

Bust of Commodus as Hercules with lion skin and club, Capitoline Museums.
Commodus as Hercules. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Commodus succeeded his father Marcus Aurelius in 180 CE after having shared imperial rank with him. His reign brought increasing anxiety among court officials over punishments, his performances in the arena and his repeated identification with Hercules. Hostile ancient authors describe him as vain and exceptionally cruel, and some transform questionable behavior into evidence of insanity. Those characterizations must be weighed carefully. The conflict between Commodus and influential members of his household, however, is a consistent feature of the surviving accounts.

On 31 December 192 CE, Marcia, who had close personal access to Commodus, joined the chamberlain Eclectus and Praetorian prefect Quintus Aemilius Laetus in a plot. Herodian’s account traces their decision to a tablet supposedly listing people whom Commodus intended to kill. A young servant is said to have found it, enabling Marcia to discover her own name and those of her associates. The episode is too neatly dramatic to verify in its details. Ancient accounts nevertheless agree in broad terms that members of the imperial household arranged the emperor’s death.

Marcia first gave Commodus poison, but he vomited and survived the immediate effects. The conspirators turned to Narcissus, an athlete and wrestling attendant who could approach him physically. Narcissus strangled the emperor. The popular description of a murder specifically inside a bath should be treated cautiously: Herodian places the attack where Commodus lay after being poisoned, and the ancient versions do not fix the precise room with certainty. The methods and involvement of palace intimates are better attested than that setting.

A marble bust of Commodus as Hercules survives in the Capitoline Museums as a striking example of how Commodus presented himself. Found at the Horti Lamiani in Rome in 1874, it depicts him with the lion skin, club and apples of Hercules. The image makes clear that his claim to the hero’s identity was publicly promoted and cannot be dismissed as an invention of unfriendly historians. Palace staff lived with those displays of imperial authority, as well as the risks of falling out of favor with Commodus himself.

Before the assassination, the plotters had selected Pertinax, an experienced senator serving as urban prefect, to succeed Commodus. He was presented as a ruler who could restore orderly government, although he owed his accession to the palace and military figures who had just orchestrated a murder. Laetus accompanied him to the Praetorian camp to obtain recognition. The soldiers who had helped secure his accession soon resisted his attempts to restrict their privileges.

Advertisements

5. Pertinax: Murdered After 87 Days (193 CE)

Bust of Pertinax, the emperor murdered by Praetorian Guards after trying to restore discipline
Bust of Pertinax. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Pertinax took power on the first day of 193 CE. A soldier and administrator of relatively modest origins, he had earned a career that the Senate respected. His promise to curb Commodus’s extravagance and arbitrary punishments appealed to senators. The Praetorians were less pleased: their rewards and privileges were threatened by his efforts to discipline the guard and repair the treasury. He had been recognized rapidly but had not settled what the soldiers expected in return for their cooperation.

The financial problem centered on the accession donative. Commodus had left the treasury under strain, and Pertinax sold imperial property in an effort to raise money. The guards remained dissatisfied and resented attempts to reduce their independence after helping install the new ruler. Cassius Dio, who was a senator at the time, was sympathetic to Pertinax but recognized the danger of introducing so many reforms at once. Military pay and imperial authority had become entangled in a dispute the emperor could not easily resolve.

On 28 March 193 CE, armed Praetorians marched from their camp into the palace. Pertinax chose to confront them instead of escaping, apparently hoping that he could appeal to their obedience and his own record. Herodian describes guards hesitating and beginning to pull back before others pushed forward. Cassius Dio says Eclectus tried to defend the emperor when the attackers struck. Pertinax was killed, and the soldiers displayed his head on a spear.

The guard next backed Didius Julianus after competing offers of money were made at its camp. Ancient authors described the incident as an auction of the empire, though the winning bid could not compel the distant legions to recognize him. Septimius Severus advanced from the Danube, Julianus was killed, and the new ruler replaced the Praetorians with soldiers loyal to himself. The guards had determined the death of one emperor without being able to control the army that chose his eventual replacement.

6. Geta: His Brother Uses Soldiers to Remove a Co-Emperor (211 CE)

Geta dies in his mother's arms after being attacked on the orders of his brother Caracalla
Geta Dying in his Mother’s Arms, Jacques Pajou. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

In 211, an emperor ordered the murder of his own brother and co-ruler. When Septimius Severus died at York in February 211 CE, he left his sons Caracalla and Geta as joint emperors. The brothers mistrusted each other, cultivated separate supporters and made their shared residence an arena for political rivalry. Julia Domna, their mother, tried to reconcile them because a violent break threatened both the Severan dynasty and the government of the empire.

In late 211, Caracalla arranged a meeting in Julia Domna’s rooms under the appearance of a reconciliation. Cassius Dio, Roman History 78.2, records that centurions carrying out Caracalla’s orders killed Geta while he clung to his mother; Dio adds that she was wounded in trying to shield him. Herodian also places the murder in her presence, though the surviving account is incomplete at the crucial point. Both writers were hostile to Caracalla and presented the scene with strong moral judgment. His responsibility for his fellow emperor’s death, however, is secure.

Caracalla hurried to the Praetorian camp and told the soldiers that he had escaped an attempt on his own life. Promised rewards helped win their support. He then pursued Geta’s allies in a purge whose scale is clear even though the death totals reported by ancient authors are uncertain. The attack continued against Geta’s public identity: inscriptions lost his name, portraits were damaged or changed, and the dynasty’s official imagery was rewritten around the surviving brother.

The policy left material evidence. A marble inscription in the British Museum’s collection contains a dedication from which the names of Geta and Plautilla were removed. The erased lettering provides physical evidence of an attempt to change the imperial family’s public memory. Men serving Caracalla had killed his co-emperor, and the new sole ruler presented the crime as an act undertaken to preserve his position and the state.

Advertisements

7. Caracalla: The Praetorian Prefect Arranges a Roadside Murder (217 CE)

Marble portrait of Caracalla, the emperor assassinated near Carrhae by a soldier linked to Macrinus
Portrait of Caracalla, 212 to 217 CE. Source: The Met.

Six years after ordering Geta’s death, Caracalla was himself stabbed by a man in his escort. He had spent much of his independent reign traveling with armies and rewarding soldiers with increased pay. That military popularity did not remove his dependence on senior officers, who knew how abruptly his favor could change. Macrinus, a Praetorian prefect in charge of important parts of his security during the campaign against Parthia, became central to the conspiracy recorded by ancient writers.

Caracalla was near Carrhae, in northern Mesopotamia close to modern Harran, during April 217. Herodian reports that Macrinus feared an accusation or ominous warning would soon be reported to the emperor. Macrinus recruited Martialis, an escort soldier whom Caracalla had allegedly insulted and whose brother he had executed. According to Herodian, the plot thus united a prefect anxious for his own survival with an officer whose personal grievances provided a reason to attack.

On 8 April, the emperor rode out with a small mounted party, away from his main army. He stopped to relieve himself, and the escorts withdrew a short distance for privacy. Martialis came close as if obeying a summons and stabbed him before anyone could intervene. Martialis escaped briefly on horseback, then cavalrymen caught and killed him. His death deprived later investigators of direct testimony about Macrinus, although there is no proof that the prefect organized the chase to eliminate the assassin.

Macrinus mourned the emperor in public and was soon acknowledged as his successor. He was the first emperor to reach the throne from the equestrian order without first belonging to the Senate, a departure from established expectations of imperial rank. Andrew Scott’s study of Cassius Dio’s account of these reigns examines how Cassius Dio constructed his judgments of Macrinus and the succeeding rulers. The new emperor’s position remained vulnerable, and in 218 troops backing Elagabalus, promoted by the Severan family, defeated him. Macrinus never secured the lasting loyalty of the troops who had supported Caracalla.

8. Elagabalus: The Praetorians Defend His Rival (222 CE)

Young emperor Elagabalus marble portrait showing teenage features
Portrait of Elagabalus, 221 CE. Source: Capitoline Museums.

Elagabalus became emperor in 218 as a teenager from Emesa in Syria, where he was a priest of the deity Elagabal. His grandmother Julia Maesa helped persuade eastern soldiers to regard him as Caracalla’s son, restoring the Severan family after Macrinus’s defeat. In Rome he raised the god he served in Emesa to greater prominence in official religious life, provoking opposition among influential Romans. Hostile accounts also used his age, Syrian origin and religious commitments to develop sensational charges of sexual and moral misconduct. Those accusations should not be accepted wholesale as explanations of the political crisis.

By 221, Julia Maesa had secured the adoption of Elagabalus’s younger cousin, the future Severus Alexander, and his designation as Caesar and heir. The adoption gave the dynasty another candidate as Elagabalus lost support. Elagabalus appears to have seen Alexander as a danger and tried to reduce his standing, while Praetorians increasingly favored the younger man. Herodian describes a report that Alexander might be dying, which led soldiers to demand proof that he was alive.

Both cousins went before the Praetorians in March 222. Alexander was warmly greeted; Elagabalus received little attention. When the emperor ordered punishment of guards who had shown their preference, the soldiers attacked him instead. They killed Elagabalus and his mother Julia Soaemias and proclaimed Alexander emperor. Herodian and Cassius Dio both describe abuse of the dead emperor’s body, though their details differ. Modern chronologies usually date the murder to 11 or 12 March.

The guards could turn against Elagabalus because a credible dynastic replacement was already beside him. His influential relatives had promoted Alexander, and the soldiers could recognize him without embarking immediately on a civil war. Martijn Icks’ study of Elagabalus and his later reputation explains how hostile ancient testimony and subsequent retellings formed Elagabalus’s notorious reputation. The assassination followed a political decision by the men responsible for imperial protection to support another Severan claimant.

9. Severus Alexander: A Frontier Army Changes Emperors (235 CE)

Portrait bust of Severus Alexander, the emperor murdered by frontier troops near the Rhine in 235 CE
Bust of Severus Alexander, ca. 230 to 235 CE. Source: The Met.

Severus Alexander was about thirteen when he inherited the throne in 222 CE. His mother Julia Mamaea and senior advisers exercised considerable influence over a government that continued the Severan dynasty for more than a decade. Problems grew more severe when campaigns against the Sasanian Persians were followed by threats from Germanic groups along the Rhine. The frontier army expected its emperor, whose experience had largely been at court, to demonstrate that he could lead and protect seasoned soldiers.

Alexander appears to have considered negotiation with enemies, perhaps including payments, and this angered some troops. Paying opponents or making alliances was an established Roman means of managing costly frontiers, especially where decisive victory was uncertain. Soldiers could nevertheless see such diplomacy as a denial of victories and rewards they hoped to win. Ancient writers also accuse Julia Mamaea of curbing military expenditure. Their portrait mixes possible complaints over resources with the familiar charge that an emperor was controlled by his mother.

The disaffected soldiers found a candidate in Maximinus, a senior officer respected within the ranks. Herodian’s narrative recounts troops hailing Maximinus while Alexander’s men withdrew their support from their emperor. In 235 Maximinus dispatched a tribune and centurions to kill Alexander and Julia Mamaea in their quarters near the Rhine. There is no reason to assume every man in the camp took part. Enough soldiers accepted the new commander, however, that the old emperor could not resist.

Later damage to imperial sculpture may preserve part of the reaction to his fall. A marble bust of Severus Alexander in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, dated to about 230–235 CE and showing the emperor in formal civic dress, has facial damage which a Metropolitan Museum publication suggests may have been inflicted deliberately after the assassination. The marks cannot identify those responsible or establish their motives. They do indicate one possible way hostility to a dead ruler could extend to public images of him.

Alexander’s death ended the Severan dynasty and was followed by the frequent changes of emperor associated with the Crisis of the Third Century. The army could overthrow a ruler, but successors still needed provincial resources, civil administration, political legitimacy and military victories to govern the empire. This murder took place in a Rhine camp, far from Rome’s Senate and Praetorian headquarters. Frontier soldiers endorsed a rival and failed to protect the emperor they had previously served.

10. Maximinus Thrax: His Army Kills Him Outside Aquileia (238 CE)

Portrait of Maximinus Thrax, the soldier emperor killed by his own troops during the siege of Aquileia
Portrait of Maximinus Thrax. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Maximinus, the officer chosen after Alexander’s death, came from the Balkan parts of the empire and had a long military career. Ancient writers described his immense size and humble origins, but many such details are unverified and colored by senatorial dislike of a ruler outside the usual aristocratic path to power. He stayed with the armies and never established a dependable relationship with the Senate. His campaigns also required heavy financial contributions from communities already burdened by military expenditure.

Opposition turned into open revolt in 238. In Africa, Gordian I and Gordian II were briefly proclaimed against Maximinus. Their revolt collapsed, but senators had already broken with him and appointed Pupienus and Balbinus as emperors. Maximinus marched into northern Italy intending to defeat his opponents. Aquileia, whose position controlled an important approach toward Rome, closed its gates. He began a siege, anticipating a quick victory by the army that had once raised him to the throne.

Aquileia’s defenders refused to surrender. Shortages of water and supplies, combined with the city’s resistance, exhausted the besieging force. Herodian’s account of the siege singles out men of the Second Parthian Legion, whose families lived near Rome, as the soldiers who moved to kill Maximinus. His bodyguard supported them or allowed them through. The troops removed the emperor’s images from their standards and killed him and his son as they came out of the tent. Their severed heads were sent to Rome as evidence that the campaign had ended.

The troops had immediate reasons to stop fighting. Their siege was failing, much of Italy opposed their ruler, and men with families near Rome feared the results of continued resistance. Maximinus could no longer guarantee their safety. The reversal was particularly sharp because soldiers dissatisfied with Severus Alexander had elevated him only three years earlier. Another group of soldiers now judged his survival more dangerous than his death.

Caligula died in a passage of the imperial palace; Maximinus was killed before Aquileia by soldiers from a besieging army. The intervening decades saw household conspiracies, rival brothers, unpaid guards and frontier mutinies. Every emperor needed armed protection, and that dependence carried a danger when the protectors found reason to abandon him. Recognition by senators, a prestigious family and the ceremonies of accession could strengthen a ruler, but none assured the loyalty of the men standing nearest to him.